DEBJENROB wrote:
jolly1 wrote:
DEBJENROB wrote:
jolly1 wrote:
jolly1 wrote:
DEBJENROB wrote:
DennisK wrote:
DEBJENROB wrote:
People agrue that if guns were registered, then the government would know who has guns and could take then away ... I could agrue that the the words ... a well regulated militia ... I could argue that the reason that was included in the Constitution was so that if the nation was threatend .... the Government could call on citizen soliders to defend the Nation .... ergo ... how could a government call on its citizens to protect the Nation if the Government does not know who is capable of defending the Nation ....also .. since we have a representitive form of government .... would anyone elect a person to be absolute dictator ..... so just who does anyone see as knocking on your door and taking away your guns ....
People agrue that if guns were registered, then th... (
show quote)
Uhhhh many do advocate for an absolute dictator.
His name is Obama.
quote=DEBJENROB People agrue that if guns were re... (
show quote)
How could that be .... he has not been able to pass any major legislation, other than health care, because the Republican majority will not agree to anything he proposes .... so how can he be a dictator ... you comment makes absolutely no sense ...
quote=DennisK quote=DEBJENROB People agrue that ... (
show quote)
quote=DEBJENROB quote=DennisK quote=DEBJENROB P... (
show quote)
So let me ask you, how did Hitler become a dictator. Better bone up on Nazi history before you answer.
quote=jolly1 quote=DEBJENROB quote=DennisK quo... (
show quote)
If you can ask that question within the context of this discussion you have not studied 20th Century History .... I can only conclude that you have absolutely no idea as to what conditions existed in Germany after WW I and the effect of the Treaty of Versalles on the German economy ...
quote=jolly1 quote=jolly1 quote=DEBJENROB quot... (
show quote)
Oh, never fear, son. I know 20th Century just fine. I lived through some of the worst of it. My father fought in WWI and was in the army of occupation, not getting home until 1921.
Then he was sent back as a ranking member of the American Embassy in 1935. We lived in Berlin for three years and saw and heard Hitler speak, in person, many times.
So I know of the conditions that existed and the effects of the Treaty of Versalles, some second hand through my father and others from personal observation and experience. So, my previous statement concerning the dictator stands.
quote=DEBJENROB quote=jolly1 quote=jolly1 quot... (
show quote)
You time spent in per-war Germany does not make you an authority on the reasons for Hitlers rise to power ... I would say that I have not read anything by any creditable Historian that links Hitlers rise to gun control ... also for you information ... gun registration requirements were in place before Hitlers rise to power .... I would think you were too young to understand the political and economic dynamics in pre- WWII Germany ....
quote=jolly1 quote=DEBJENROB quote=jolly1 quot... (
show quote)
Never stated that I was an authority because of my stay. I merely said that I was there. Later that time reinforced what I learned in school, in government service, and in educational reading for pleasure. I've always been interested in the subject because of my having been there. I assume that your total knowledge of the subject is just enough to argue with anyone
who makes you feel like an idiot.
I would say that you have not read anything, by anybody, on this matter until most recently.
What gun registration existed in Germany before Hitler was not enforced to any noticable degree. That is the reason that one of Hitler's first official actions was to decree that all firearms of any type, be surrendered to the authorities immediately. Prison was the answer to any disobedience.
And how old were you, little man, during the period in question?Yes, I was too young to understand the political and economic
dynamics in pre-WWII Germany, but I did experience them, and that leaves a lasting impression on a young person.
You read, possibly, such things from books, I lived them. I will stand my experiences and later knowledge up against anything you can possibly come up with.
quote=DEBJENROB quote=jolly1 quote=DEBJENROB q... (