billnikon wrote:
I only use two lenses for landscape photography. The Nikon 16-35 mm f4 (90% of the time) and the Nikon 24-120 f 4 (10% of the time), I use these two because they share the same filter size.
Sounds like you are set on the Tokina, but I find a 11-16 a little two wide for most of the things I shoot. Below is an example of the 16-35. This was a photo of a water fall in a small town in Vermont, the old mill can be seen in the background.
The 16-35mm lens is for FX while the 11-16 is for DX. Both have similar fields of view.
If the OP needs a faster lens for low light get the Tokina. If not the Nikon that you have is fine. I have both the 12-24mm f/4 and 17-35mm f/4 Tokina for my FX and DX cameras and they are both fantastic lenses. Much lower distortion than Nikon's current UWA (ultra wide angle) lenses. The only thing is that the 12-24mm only works on D7000 series and DX cameras that have a focus motor (screw drive auto focus). Not a problem for me but you need to make sure if your camera has this option.
The Tokina you mention comes in two types. The older Pro lens was screw drive while the Pro II version is a built in focus motor.
Either way you look at it the Tokina's are a great deal as they are built like a tank and made to last. Night and day difference from the newer plastic lenses that die if you look at them the wrong way.