billnikon wrote:
Find-tuning is only good for the distance you set it at. No thanks. My 40 AF Nikon lenses focus just fine, and I go 16X24 and 20X30 without issue for years.
I have NEVER had a need to fine focus any Nikon lens.
That first sentence is an incorrect statement in regards to how the Tamron TAP-in process works, or at the very least dismissive and shows a lack of understanding about what the Tamron TAP-in does. Perhaps an explanation of exactly what it does is in order. Follow me here...
If you were shooting pictures of a subject at
one distance using
one lens at
one focal length using
one camera body, and if your camera has an AF fine-tune setting, most might agree it worthwhile to fine tune the AF focus to make sure the focus is tack sharp.
Just in case the image was back- or forward- focused by a millimeter or two.
Now, say you change the focal length, and you were a real perfectionist, you'd feel like you had to go in and change that AF fine tune number for the new focal length each time - what a pain in the rear! Your statement of "only good for the distance you set it at" would seem to hold true. However....
The idea behind the Tamron TAP-in is to do the above-mentioned procedure, but for multiple focal lengths and distance. You enter those 'tuned in' values on the Tamron TAP-in program, and it uses those points to create a 'continuous' curve fit algorithm (in engineering-speak, likely a 3rd or 4th order polynomial equation). That correction algorithm is programmed into the G2 lens using the TAP-in console (which is connected to your computer via USB).
When using the programmed G2 lens, you set the AF fine tune on your camera to
zero. The G2 sends the needed AF 'fine tune' correction value at
every focal length and distance for the best AF focus.
I have a Tamron 24-70 G2 used with a Nikon D600 that I dialed using the TAP-in console. For that lens, the TAP-in has you fine tune the AF using 4 focal lengths (24,35, 50, & 70mm) at 3 distances (1.25, 3, and 11.5 feet). That's 12 (3 x 4) data points that is used do make the correction algorithm for the 24-70 G2 / D600 combination I own.
After tuning, the AF is as sharp as possible for all focal lengths from 24mm to 70mm, near or far focal distance. It will be 'right on' at 24, 35, 50, & 70mm, but even the 'in between' points like 42mm, 62mm - whatever - focal lengths will be nearly as accurate due to the curve fit algorithm mentioned before. This yields continuous AF fine tuning throughout the entire focal length of the lens. Now I have much better AF performance over then entire 24-70mm range, especially at 70mm.
To me, the Tamron TAP-in tuning makes a TON of sense. I refuse to believe that mass produced "prosumer" lenses like the Nikon 200-500 or the Tamron 150-600 G2 will operate perfectly out of the box without some calibration, and Nikon's lack of something like the TAP-in has me leaning heavily toward and saving up for the Tamron 150-600 G2.