Lucian wrote:
Keep the sky in, it gives depth, especially the fall off in focus as it stretches out to the horizon. Without that in the image it would look to cramped and too busy with too much sea.
Change the crop so that it is half way from the original and your cropped version. In other words, you have half as much sea below the surfer again, as you did in your crop, but not as much as in the uncropped version.
I like the overall impact but would suggest that you decrease the contrast slightly and take your tinted version and reduce the colour/tint to about 80% less, so that it is just above a B&W with just a hint of Sepia Tint in the image.
Then you'll have an interesting and thought provoking print. You may also try a hint of dark blue tint and then try one with a hint of pink tint or burnt sienna.
Keep the sky in, it gives depth, especially the fa... (
show quote)