Thanks so much for the in depth suggestions. I am shopping, and maybe making more of this than I should, but I can't afford to waste $400-600. Escaroles on stuff that's going to not do the job. My bag doesn't include really heavy stuff, so I think with all these suggestions from my fellow Hogs, I can make an educated purchase, so much easier than I could have before.
amfoto1 wrote:
The Manrotto MT055CXPRO3 is a sturdy, carbon fiber tripod.
Three things to consider...
1. Working height. Is it tall enough that you can use it without raising the center column at all. For best stability it's better to not raise the center column (or get a tripod that doesn't have one at all). According to the specs at B&H Photo, the tripod itself is 55" tall without raising the center column. Add in the height of the head and the distance from the bottom of your camera to the viewfinder eyepiece, to see if this is enough for you to comfortably work with it.
2. I see that the center column on this tripod rotates for horizontal use, such as for a lower angle macro shot. That might also effect stability, even when being used in the "normal" vertical position. I don't know one way or another... it's something you should check out yourself. If this is a feature you don't think you'll ever need, you might look at another model without it.
3. Leg latches. This Manfrotto uses lever-type latches, that are quick to use. However, they do wear over time (Manfrotto usually includes an Allen wrench with their tripods to adjust the latch tension). They also can catch on branches, cuffs and sleeves. Personally I prefer the twist-type leg locks, which are lower profile and generally self-adjusting. They are a little slower to use, have to be done in a particular order with many tripods, and some care not to over-tighten is important.
Regarding the quick release system. As some others have mentioned, Manfrotto uses their own, proprietary type of quick releases platforms and plates. They are common enough that they aren't hard to find, and might be fine.
However, the Arca-Swiss style quick release system is far more universal... In use by dozens of different manufacturers. So it's even easier to find compatible parts for. And it's necessary or at least very helpful for some things... such as gimbal heads (really large lenses with tripod rings), macro shooting and more.
Not long ago I got a Smith-Victor BH8 ballhead for one of my tripods. It only cost $60, so I honestly wasn't expecting much, although it's claimed to be able to support 50 lbs. I was pleasantly surprised, though, how close it was to the Kirk BH-1 ($385, also rated for 50 lbs) that I use on another tripod. One problem with the BH8 when it first arrived, was that the panning axis was a bit stiff. I disassembled it (easy, just a few screws), removed the heavy grease that was used on the ball bearings and replaced it with a heavy oil (bicycle chain oil, in fact). It's now smooth as a baby's cheek! Yeah, it's true... the S-V BH8 ain't as refined as the Kirk BH-1. The BH8 has little rubber grips on the knobs that might need to be replaced or glued back on eventually... not the nice, machine knurled knobs on the BH-1. But, hey, it's a BALLHEAD... not a fine Swiss watch! Works fine.
Both mine are rather large/heavy duty ballheads (necessary with some of the lenses and cameras I use on them). For your purposes, the Kirk BH-3 or Smith-Victor BH5 or even smaller BH2 might be more than adequate.... as well as cheaper, smaller and lighter weight.
Something else you might want to consider is an L-bracket for your camera. Ballheads... most tripod heads of any type, for that matter... tend to be unbalanced when you switch them to put the camera into vertical/portrait orientation. An L-bracket that attaches to your camera relatively permanently eliminates the problem by providing QR platforms both on the bottom and on the side of the camera body. If interested in using one of these, I am not aware of any that are compatible with Manfrotto quick release systems. You will find most L-brackets are Arca-Swiss style compatible. (Note: All the heads I mentioned above are A-S compatible, though there's a "retaining safety lock" button that needs to be unscrewed from the Smith-Victor heads, when used with some A-S plates).
An alternative is to modify a Manfrotto head to work with Arca-Swiss. I have a smaller Bogen/Manfrotto ballhead I use on a monopod that I've modified this way... simply replacing the QR platform on it with one made by Kirk. That adds about $45 to $55 cost, though (I already had the ballhead from something else, so it was a no-brainer to mod it.) There also are adapters to make non-QR heads into Arca-Swiss style QR.
Have fun shopping!
The Manrotto MT055CXPRO3 is a sturdy, carbon fiber... (
show quote)