claytonsummers wrote:
Looking through photos on this site and others, I've noticed more and more pictures with (to me anyway) obnoxious HDR halos. Areas that are dark get pulled up and the brighter areas next to the dark area gets brightened also, giving it a halo effect. It winds up looking over cooked. Artistically, I can see why some might like this, but to me it just jumps out and distracts from the rest of the photo.
I was thinking about this over the last few days and realized that most modern pop music is doing the same thing. They compress the dynamic range of the recording to get a consistent volume over the length of the song. Quiet regions get amplified and loud regions get attenuated. Compared to older recordings where the loud and soft passages are an important part of the experience, these compressed recording feel very artificial and annoying, much like the over cooked HDR photos.
When I first got interested in High Fidelity sound years ago, the openness and naturalness of the sound created was always a very important part of the experience. Boom boxes and music processed for loud
clubs and radio changed the way most music got produced. Today, I think we are seeing something similar with the shift to HDR and overcooked post processing. Loud and thumpy music, loud and in your face photos.
Looking through photos on this site and others, I'... (
show quote)
Agree. I think good HDR processing does not look like HDR to the casual eye. Similarly, good noise reduction and sharpening, when done subtly, do not scream, but quietly cause the capture to mirror the original scene as seen by the eye.