billnikon wrote:
When I taught photography, I had my students bring in their work on slides after I gave an assignment, then I would put the slide up on the screen. I would always give a positive, sometimes it was difficult, but after some positives I would give some suggestions on how to make the image better.
I had some students who elected not to bring any images in, and that was OK, they learned from watching others images.
Your way of critiques, positive first then suggestions for improvement, the best way to learn. There will always be those who learn by looking at the work of others. Unfortunately there are those who think they know and are not open to the views or opinions of others. Nothing can be done about them.