I Read Your Post and u state u have taught others the use of Lightroom organizing skills have you and video tutorials or pdf. tutorials that one could learn from?? Thanks CJsFotos.
Gene51 wrote:
Easier to edit individual files in Capture One, but I do that in LR by simply setting up a "temp" folder that is polled by LR. When something shows up, either by tethered capture or simply by my importing a file into this "watched" folder, it is added to the catalog and I can edit, save the edits, or delete the whole thing. This is how I manage students' work when they need my advice and guidance on an image.
Anyway, I completely understand the question, because you, like nearly everyone I know that has thought about using LR, are concerned about and have reservations about how the catalog works. You also do not have an understanding about how it works.
I will tell you a short story - I have had a file structure that is pretty well organized, just the way I like it, since 2000. I began using LR in 2011. My file structure is still completely intact. If you look in Windows Explorer, the main folder where my pictures are, you cannot detect at what point I began using LR. Nothing has changed. I import the files to my computer using LR, but instead of first creating the folder and copying the files as I used to do, I open the import dialog, select copy files, and specify where they go - and LR creates the folder on the fly. I could also just do as I have always done, and navigate to the folder in the folder view in LR's Library module and sync the folder, and use the Add option to just add the files to the catalog without moving or creating copies of them.
The advantage of a catalog/database is that it is simple and organized. Rating, Tagging, Keywording, creating multiple virtual collections, etc is so fast and easy. As an example, I have some pictures in several collections, lets call them waterfalls, cats and dogs, landscapes, small birds, large birds. I needed to assemble a group of 21 images in a new collection for an art exhibit, using some of the images in the other collections. I created a new collection called Aug 26 exhibit and made it the target collection. As I reviewed the images in each of the contributing collections I click on the B key to add the image to the collection. If I change my mind afterwards or if when viewing the target collection I find I need to remove images from the collection, I press B again to remove it from the current collection. I have over 100,000 images, but this process took me less than 15 mins, and I did not have to mess around with creating folders, moving or copying files, etc, as I would have in the past.
I am able to teach this to complete newbies that are not particularly computer savvy in a matter of a couple of hours, and it makes perfect sense to them, and they begin using it immediately.
I do not see any value in disabling the catalog - what is it that you feel you would gain by turning it off?
Easier to edit individual files in Capture One, bu... (
show quote)