frankraney wrote:
Bill, a DX24mm on a crop body has a fov of 24mm, but COMPARED to an FX is 36..... The DX body sees the DX lens as it is, 24mm...... They are designed to go together. Right?
NO, but the whole concept is difficult to grasp.
Look at it this way, a DX lens is designed to cover a SMALLER sensor, a DX lens is designed specifically for a DX (cropped sensor body). A FX lens is designed to cover a LARGER sensor. I hope you follow this so far.
SO, if you put a DX lens on a FX body, it will not cover the LARGER sensor of the FX body and you will get vignetting in the corners of the sensors. BUT, if you put a FX lens on a DX body, the FX lens will actually spill over the coverage of the DX sensor BUT can still be used, BUT, you can only use the center of the FX lens because at over covers the corners of the DX sensor.
NOW, this is the confusing part, ANY lens on a cropped sensor camera has a crop factor of 1.5, that is for ANY lens you mount on a crop sensor camera.
Look at this lens from B&H, the Nikon DX 18-200, look at how B&H describes the angle of view, they say,
"27-300mm (35mm Equivalent)". They are trying NOT to confuse anyone, but what they are actually saying is that on a CROPPED DX body, the lens will have an angle of view of 27-300 mm.
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/search?Ntt=nikon%2018-200&N=0&InitialSearch=yes&sts=ma&Top+Nav-Search=
So, any lens put on a DX body is going to receive a cropped 1.5 effect. (For either a DX or FX lens.)
So, getting back to your statement. A DX 24 mm lens on a cropped sensor camera actually has a field of view of 36 mm, not 24 mm. Any lens you mount on a DX body, either a DX or FX lens, will get a 1.5 multiplication field of view factor.
OK, the other part is this, the DX body does not see, it can only respond to any lens put on it, so, the DX 24 mm lens (which by the way does not exist) on a DX body will yield a field of view of 36 mm. And yes, a DX lens is designed to go on a DX camera, that part you understand.
The only confusing part is that you just have to except the fact that ANY lens put on a DX body will receive a 1.5 increase in it's field of view. ANY LENS.
I probably confused you further but I tried, still have not drank my coffee.