Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
After market batteries
Page <<first <prev 4 of 7 next> last>>
Jan 24, 2021 13:34:49   #
wetreed
 
I have never had any trouble with a third party battery. In fact they work just as well as the ome . I can’t wait to how many old foggies come out from under the woodwork to say it’s not worth it.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 13:52:14   #
chrissybabe Loc: New Zealand
 
Like everything in life if you buy the cheapest then you will most likely get junk. But in saying that there is a mid point where the batteries are just as good as OEM but much cheaper. We use Wasabi and have saved over a $1000.

You also need to be aware that there is a subset of the population who have some weird mental condition that will only allow them to buy "name brand". Happens with cars, cameras & batteries, stereos, grocery products, clothing and shoes (especially), hand bags, power tools and others.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:00:10   #
Silverrails
 
DonVA wrote:
I'm shooting with a Canon RP which I love but battery life is very poor compared to the 7D I was using before. This means I need to have a few extra batteries in my bag but Canon batteries are expensive. You get what you pay for though and the cheap aftermarket batteries I've bought don't have the capacity and they don't live long. Can anyone recommend an aftermarket brand that matches the quality of the Canon batteries? They obviously wouldn't be the cheapest batteries out there but they're bound to be less money than the Canons.
Thanks
I'm shooting with a Canon RP which I love but batt... (show quote)


For the Safety of your Camera and Flash it has been suggested by other Professional Photographers that use Nikon Batteries with Nikon Cameras, Use Canon Batteries with Canon Cameras, Etc. Off brand Batteries do not perform at 100%, also have occasionally been known to damage Cameras.

Reply
 
 
Jan 24, 2021 14:04:06   #
joer Loc: Colorado/Illinois
 
DonVA wrote:
I'm shooting with a Canon RP which I love but battery life is very poor compared to the 7D I was using before. This means I need to have a few extra batteries in my bag but Canon batteries are expensive. You get what you pay for though and the cheap aftermarket batteries I've bought don't have the capacity and they don't live long. Can anyone recommend an aftermarket brand that matches the quality of the Canon batteries? They obviously wouldn't be the cheapest batteries out there but they're bound to be less money than the Canons.
Thanks
I'm shooting with a Canon RP which I love but batt... (show quote)


Take battery advice with a grain of salt. Mirrorless cameras consume more power than DSLR. Batteries that work well in a DSLR will not perform as well in a ML camera. Batteries perform differently in different devices. To be safe buy the original.

Exact equivalents are out there...Canon don't make batteries. The only sure way to find a comparable battery is by trying the different brands.

Although another way to look at it is initial cost vs performance. If your battery only provides 2/3 the life but it cost less than 1/2 of the original...get the point.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:13:01   #
ShelbyDave Loc: Lone Rock, WI
 
Canon batteries are overpriced. I bought several off brand batteries for $6 each and I never had any issues with them. Fit well, lasted as long as the Canon. Still have three of them (all about 10 years old) so I am hesitant to sell them even though I have sold the camera they went with. I looked and unfortunately there is no name on them. If I had to do it again I would.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:21:25   #
johngault007 Loc: Florida Panhandle
 
Silverrails wrote:
For the Safety of your Camera and Flash it has been suggested by other Professional Photographers that use Nikon Batteries with Nikon Cameras, Use Canon Batteries with Canon Cameras, Etc. Off brand Batteries do not perform at 100%, also have occasionally been known to damage Cameras.


If we want to go down that road, OEM batteries have also been known to damage cameras. Guess we are in a pickle.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:28:32   #
tropics68 Loc: Georgia
 
joer wrote:
Take battery advice with a grain of salt. Mirrorless cameras consume more power than DSLR. Batteries that work well in a DSLR will not perform as well in a ML camera. Batteries perform differently in different devices. To be safe buy the original.

Exact equivalents are out there...Canon don't make batteries. The only sure way to find a comparable battery is by trying the different brands.

Although another way to look at it is initial cost vs performance. If your battery only provides 2/3 the life but it cost less than 1/2 of the original...get the point.
Take battery advice with a grain of salt. Mirrorle... (show quote)


Is there any for sure way to determine the "OEM" battery is in fact not a Chinese knockoff? I once purchased a Canon battery that was advertised as OEM from a "reputable dealer". The battery was junk. It looked exactly like the battery that came with the camera new. I got about 25 pictures and it was dead. The dealer took it back and did not offer to replace it so I just moved on down the line to an advertised third party battery. I have several cameras and have had no real issues with known 3rd party batteries which usually DO NOT last as long as the real OEM version. joel is right. It is all about bang for the buck!

Reply
 
 
Jan 24, 2021 14:31:23   #
chrissybabe Loc: New Zealand
 
OEM camera batteries are expensive, OEM inks for printers are expensive, OEM parts for cars are expensive. In a lot of cases there are alternatives that will last as long but be much cheaper.
Capitalism says if the market is captive then charge as much as you can. Since the OEM battery probably costs the same to make as an off brand one (and possibly in the same factory) then some simple calculations will make this much clearer. Note that camera makers are in the business of making cameras - batteries happen to be a necessary evil that they unfortunately have to provide to be able to sell the cameras. I think you will find they would rather sell 10 batteries at $80 than 20 at $40 since less inventory and handling etc. Simple economics.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:39:51   #
chrissybabe Loc: New Zealand
 
None of the 3rd party batteries we use have shown any tendency to run for less time than the OEM. If you apply the same principles to using batteries to filling your gas tank then you shouldn't have a problem. Just as you would never wait until the car actual stops before refilling with fuel you should also never use the camera until the battery won't function ie it's dead. If you are a prolific shooter then put a new battery in midday regardless of the state of the current one. If you are one of those who only has one battery then pull your finger out and get a 2nd one, or even a 3rd one. If you are only running with one battery then I guess you are also not bothering to make a 2nd copy of your shots either (backups).

And I should mention that over the last 20 years, although we have chosen some very crappy non OEM batteries (which we quickly replaced) with good makes we have never had a battery dribble into or damage a camera. In fact the only time we have been caught out was once an OEM battery (in a Canon P&S) expanded and extraction wasn't easy.

Buy OEM if you have too much money or you can tax write them off. Or have the name brand problem.
Okay I am trolling a little bit here but the answers on here seem to be extreme in both directions but there is a good middle ground where you don't pay a fortune and get good value.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:40:07   #
Silverrails
 
ShelbyDave wrote:
Canon batteries are overpriced. I bought several off brand batteries for $6 each and I never had any issues with them. Fit well, lasted as long as the Canon. Still have three of them (all about 10 years old) so I am hesitant to sell them even though I have sold the camera they went with. I looked and unfortunately there is no name on them. If I had to do it again I would.


Interesting Experience indeed, What "Off-Brand" Batteries do you recommend using for a Nikon Brand, they might act differently with a different brand. $6.00 battery is definitley a deal, IF they DO NOT DAMAGE your expensive Camera.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 14:57:46   #
chrissybabe Loc: New Zealand
 
Silverrails wrote:
Interesting Experience indeed, What "Off-Brand" Batteries do you recommend using for a Nikon Brand, they might act differently with a different brand. $6.00 battery is definitley a deal, IF they DO NOT DAMAGE your expensive Camera.


I use Wasabi but there are others. I have found that $6 batteries are well to steer clear of but when an OEM is $80 there are good batteries around for $30-50 that work well and last as long. Adding comments like "do not damage your expensive camera" is scare mongering.
Several commenters on here have pointed out the brands that they have found to work okay. Do some research.
The killer will be the day that manufacturers insert code into the OEM batteries and code into the camera that checks for the 'correct' battery. The day after I discover that happening will be the same day that brand (camera) is removed from my consider purchasing list. Do not underestimate the power of a marketing department to make some really stupid decisions.
Same thing happening with power tools. Although I use 3 different brands of tools I only use a single battery make (Makita, and clones, as it happens). If I cannot buy an adapter then I don't buy that make of tool.

Reply
 
 
Jan 24, 2021 15:27:01   #
johonew
 
rmalarz wrote:
I agree with Sidwalkastronomy. However, I'll add this the mix. What if one of those batteries goes south and damages your camera. If it's an OEM battery there's no argument about the possible repair bill. If it's an after market battery, the company may not even want to repair it.
--Bob


Considering what I paid for my SONY camera and lenses, and the fact that I have seen firsthand off-brand batteries 'expand' with my Fuji, I now opt to spend a little more for OEM batteries and agree wholeheartedly with rmalarz.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 15:50:14   #
Chris13 Loc: St. Pete, FL
 
Another vote for Wasabi batteries. Over the years and through various cameras they beat OEM every time in every way. A $300 gym shoe that says "Nike" on it is still just a $50 gym shoe.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 15:50:40   #
ronpier Loc: Poland Ohio
 
Scruples wrote:
When I purchased my new camera, I noticed the batteries drained very quickly. So I kept it off most of the time. I also don’t use the LCD screen that much when on. The Screen draws a lot of power especially if the screen articulates. I don’t like the thought of using third party manufacturer batteries. My biggest fear (probably unfounded) is if the third party battery leaks inside the camera. It’s not very pretty and likely to be expensive to repair. I have purchased a total of five batteries which translates to about $400. These batteries were purchased over several trips to B&H in NYC.

I am not an expert in Canon EOS RP but I think that you could save battery juice by shutting off everything. Then putting the camera in the bag.
When I purchased my new camera, I noticed the batt... (show quote)

Or just carry an extra OEM battery instead of shutting everything off. At $50-80 this is an inexpensive way to double battery life.

Reply
Jan 24, 2021 16:04:45   #
ronpier Loc: Poland Ohio
 
kufengler wrote:
In the distant past I've used non-OEM Batteries but had bad luck with some. From then on I went with OEM batteries and accessories. For me it wasn't worth the few dollars I save initially compared to buying the OEM brand to start with. I forgot where I bought mine.
Check Walmart, I found the battery for $49.99 there.
https://www.walmart.com/ip/Canon-LP-E17-Battery-Li-Ion-1040-mAh-for-EOS-200-250-800-850-9000-Kiss-X10-Kiss-X9i-M6-Rebel-SL3-Rebel-T7i-Rebel-T8i-RP/46118182


My original OEM battery in my Nikon D50 just started its 16th year of service. For this reason I make every attempt to purchase OEM unless it’s no longer available. This happened only once because it was needed during the Holidays for a backup.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 7 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.