Beautiful pictures indeed. Thx for sharing!
I like all of them but by a small margin I think the third is best. Good luck!
Best is #2 do not crop the off site is great composition
pmsc70d wrote:
Our county fair allows only one entry per category. I have several in mind for the "Wildlife" category, and don't know which to choose. What would you choose?
Thanks!
I think #2 is the winner. Best of luck. >Alan
[quote=pmsc70d]Our county fair allows only one entry per category. I have several in mind for the "Wildlife" category, and don't know which to choose. What would you choose?
Do it, Do it! They are all really good but my favorite is the second one, The Hawk on a fence, or pole holding his prey under his left foot/claw thingy.
Number 2 is the best of the lot. I wouldn't crop on the right. Negative space gives the subject more of a dynamic scene. See if you can add a little more light on camera left on the subject. I suspect the nearest eye will be virtually black when printed otherwise.
pmsc70d wrote:
Our county fair allows only one entry per category. I have several in mind for the "Wildlife" category, and don't know which to choose. What would you choose?
Thanks!
They are all nice but #2 is probably the best for competition.
stanikon
Loc: Deep in the Heart of Texas
1 or 2 - either one would be very good, especially in a competition. Definitely NOT #3, which is a good photo in its own right but would not do well in a competition. #4 is iffy, but falls behind #1 and #2.
I would not crop the osprey. It needs to be off-center for dramatic effect.
A lot depends on what the judges are looking for but I would go with either 2 or 4.
kstephens43 wrote:
RRS,
I find your comments most arrogant, and certainly not supportable. Unless you have won first place in every competition you have entered (you haven't), and unless your photography is world famous (it isn't), then you should tone the outward expression of your opinion down a bit.
Photography is inherently subjective, and no photographer should ever assume that his own subjectivity is the standard by which all others are judged.
In county fairs, the "quality" of the judging is highly variable. In many cases, the judges opt for photos the average non-photographer would like. Nitpicking subtle differences in sharpness, etc. are almost always secondary.
I have won Gold awards in Photographic Society of America International competitions, yet my first attempts at entering competitions such as county fairs was frustrating. It was hard for me to realize that the judges were not using my standards (or the standards most of us in this forum would appreciate). Once I realized that, I was able to win such contests with photos you would probably dislike.
RRS, br br I find your comments most arrogant, an... (
show quote)
You make a lot of assumptions and don't know a thing about me. I'm happy for you that after winning a PSA competition you get joy out of competing in county fair photo events. I only ever entered one photo contest and no I did not win but did make the final judging in a world wide contest with over one hundred thousand entries. I don't do contest but I have judged several and you are right it is subjective.
Photography has changed and so have I, film to digital. We are no longer limited to what a professional printer could do for us in a chemical darkroom for a price, I know because that's what I did for a living for years. Still today we have composition, exposure, tone , color and last but not least sharpness in this digital world with software available to everyone. Unless you are a (SOOC) straight out of camera shooter you will need to learn and develop some computer skills to be a complete photographer.
I feel that you are doing a disservice and being dishonest with someone, if asked to comment, if you aren't truthful with what you say. Yes, what and how you say it makes a big difference. I'll say it again, too many times on sites like this, people give a wow factor because they can't bring themselves to something that isn't positive. There have been several members here that have posted two pictures and asked , A or B, for a contest and they were darn good shots, I'll bet by your standards too .
I wish the OP all the luck in the world, I would not advise him on what picture to submit but advise him to rethink his selection or rework what he has shown. I've been involved with photography since 1954 and for over 30 years made a good living as a photographer and printer and along the way I've learned a thing or two.
stanikon
Loc: Deep in the Heart of Texas
I have only entered one contest. It was a local county fair here in Texas. The photo I entered was of the remains of a dead tree, which is OK, but it is in California. I won Best of Show, and never did tell them they were looking at a California tree.
stanikon wrote:
I have only entered one contest. It was a local county fair here in Texas. The photo I entered was of the remains of a dead tree, which is OK, but it is in California. I won Best of Show, and never did tell them they were looking at a California tree.
Must have been a great shot, would it have made a difference if someone had asked, I hope not. I was in on a PPA print competition and one of the several judges scored a print very low, so low that the judging stopped while a panel of judges had a discussion on the final score. It turns out that the judge in question had visited the actual place where the shot had been taken and thought that something of interest had been left out. Needless to say his vote was thrown out, you just never know.
Congratulations for "Best in Show" !
#2 is great. Crop a little from the top and right side. Most of the others have to much foliage, limbs, branches that interferes with or takes away from the subject.
Another vote for the osprey. Great shot!!
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.