Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
For beginners, M or AUTO?
Page <<first <prev 15 of 21 next> last>>
Sep 24, 2022 09:33:53   #
CHG_CANON Loc: the Windy City
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
______________________(reply)

Clever example. I appreciate the comparison since I have never owned a car or truck with automatic anything.-----------ew


Why are you back?

Reply
Sep 24, 2022 10:31:04   #
fhayes Loc: Madison, Tennessee
 
CHG_CANON wrote:
If you don't know anything, why bother with the most complex that most of the UHH community with all their age and experience still don't understand?


hahahahahahaha ouch!! hahahahaha

Reply
Sep 24, 2022 11:28:14   #
mindzye Loc: WV
 
PhotogHobbyist wrote:
Comparison of driving a car and taking photos sounds like it would be like apples to oranges, but it may be more realistic than meets the eye.

Learning to do anythig manually takes concentration and practice to master all the functions of the process. To learn an automated process is extremely simple as the mechanism performs many of the processes. An example in my mind is, learning to drive a car with a manual transmission then switching to automatic is very easy to do. The other direction as described by you is more difficult. Learning a manual process, in reality, is learning how to do both, manual and automatic. That results in the learner to have the opportunity to make a choice more easily.
Comparison of driving a car and taking photos soun... (show quote)


Piggybacking on your car analogy I feel it is very similar. Case in point - when I was 18 and behind the wheel of a '65 Mustang 289 4-speed I learned how to feel the road w/ gear changing, braking, accelerating, etc. One night in Nashville a buddy-' 73 Vega !!, yeah I know.... - were off to the side of a side road in the evening. A fellow high school student w/ brand new '74 Trans Am slowed down and gave us both the finger. "T" looked at me and pointed down the road. Climbing on the TA at around 80, intersection to the main road coming up, light red. His braking gave me the opportunity to close the gap and with the light now green he accelerated. Problem was his nose was all over the place at the speed he was going and the back was following. He obviously didn't have a clue as to what he was doing, or the capabilities of this fantastic car. The 289 was screaming through rpm's downshifting and I thought he's going to kill us both. Yet knowing how my car handled I put the 'Stang' into an intentional powerslide
downshifting to rev and hit the power band, control the steering and doing what is now called a "Swedish slide" and with tires burning and engine screaming, w/intentional control of the steering I slid around him at probably no more than 65 mph. Eased grip of the wheel, let it right itself after! braking 'till the apex of the turn and nailed it, pulling out of the slide and again asking more of the engine that it was usually asked. Passed him on the uphill side and caught just a bit of air on the downside. He wouldn't come up to me at the light at McDonald's. sheesh what a wuss. Was just having fun............Point is, his TA could outperform that Mustang in all performance categories,except one: knowing your equipment and knowing how and when to use it. Not training, just experience. Well, training right after the times you needed said experience...........
ps I now wonder why I never thought about the cops....well, they Were involved at some other time(s)......... youth, ignorance, guts, and wondering how far one can push things - except Dad and, well, the cops......

Kind of like my first Pentax K-1000. Basic settings. "sorry no pictures, no neg's on the strip" to develop on the package(s). sheeesh And figuring out what I did wrong.
Push processing of film. Learning to intentionally under/ over expose a particular brand of film; Kodak, Agafa, Ilford, etc. Lots of money on b&w contact sheets & prints. Notes on what I did - mostly so I wouldn't 'did it' again.
Learning the limits in steering your equipment to get the most of the camera.

Knowing the basics and then elevating your game is part of the joy of photography. And then you can ask of it to produce what you 'see' and then of what the camera is capable.

And yet again, if one just wants to push a button ( pro's excluded here) then they can be happy w/ mediocre performance, compared to what their equipment may be able to offer.

Reply
 
 
Sep 24, 2022 12:29:41   #
radiojohn
 
Good idea. People learn in different ways, some by doing, some by hearing and some by seeing.

Reply
Sep 24, 2022 13:21:22   #
User ID
 
petrochemist wrote:
My view exactly. It's true that we learn quicker when young, but learning the features in controlled stages is certainly no harder than having to deal with everything at once. I'd expect it to be considerably easier unless you remain on auto for long enough for age to become relevant.

The camera ages faster than the user. Better that noobsters learn their first camera in Auto and their next camera in P-mode followed by a verrrrrry advanced model to learn full manual.

It would help minimize noobster confusion if the very advanced third camera uses a different lens mount than the prior two cameras but accepts an OEM adapter that uses an earlier lens mount of a different brand. This way each step in the learning process will be distinct and not blur into the adjacent steps.

Reply
Sep 24, 2022 13:24:41   #
therwol Loc: USA
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
____________________(reply)

----those who start their photo interest in manual can easily shift to auto for quick shooting, but those who are the "point and shooters"---have more trouble learning manual shooting.---


Reality check. Times have changed. Phones are the tool of choice for taking pictures for just about everyone. Photo interest isn't starting with adjustable cameras. I don't think that most people even realize the limitations of phones. Those who eventually do will already have had much experience with "point and shoot" photography. Those who are motivated will buy a camera and learn how to change what's under the hood to take better pictures. Most people will not.

Reply
Sep 24, 2022 18:59:25   #
Blues Dude
 
therwol wrote:
The so called newbies have probably already been using a phone for pictures for a long time. They didn't start with a dedicated camera. You may even have a hard time convincing them that they can do more with a camera than a phone. But if you can convince them to try a dedicated camera, I would suggest leaving them in their familiar territory of automatic exposure etc. and then point out other options to them as time goes on.


I agree. Start the newbies with fully auto, and the ones who like a challenge will try the other options, at their own speed. Just be thankful you don't have to pay for their film and processing anymore while they learn. 😎

Reply
 
 
Sep 25, 2022 22:56:58   #
MDI Mainer
 
This is 2022. What is a stick shift? What is onion skin? What is a mimeograph? What is a switchboard?

Reply
Sep 25, 2022 23:05:52   #
User ID
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
____________________(reply)

Just how did I know there would be a disagreement and wrong-headed reply??? I thought maybe this topic might be free of snarky remarks---but no. I posted another remark on the IR topic----maybe you should critique that one?-----ew (Maybe you didn't get the nuance of the automobile topic? Should I explain it to you?---i.e.----those who start their photo interest in manual can easily shift to auto for quick shooting, but those who are the "point and shooters"---have more trouble learning manual shooting.---got it now?----------------ew-----Are you the snarky in Figi Islands?---from early this year?
____________________(reply) br br Just how did I ... (show quote)

ROTFLMFAO again ....


(Download)


(Download)


(Download)


(Download)

Reply
Sep 25, 2022 23:09:46   #
OldSchool-WI Loc: Brandon, Wisconsin 53919
 
MDI Mainer wrote:
This is 2022. What is a stick shift? What is onion skin? What is a mimeograph? What is a switchboard?


____________________(Reply)

and go back farther a stick shift was often called the "wobble stick." Cars like the 37 Chev, a popular car with teens in my day.------

Reply
Sep 25, 2022 23:16:11   #
OldSchool-WI Loc: Brandon, Wisconsin 53919
 
User ID wrote:
ROTFLMFAO again ....


So------once again, the MONITOR is a sleep at the switch and the three or four "spoiling snarkies" take over.--------Wonder why there are fewer and fewer topics in discussion????????????????????

Reply
 
 
Sep 26, 2022 05:29:09   #
User ID
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
So------once again, the MONITOR is a sleep at the switch and the three or four "spoiling snarkies" take over.--------Wonder why there are fewer and fewer topics in discussion????????????????????


(Download)


(Download)

Reply
Sep 26, 2022 09:00:54   #
rehess Loc: South Bend, Indiana, USA
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
So------once again, the MONITOR is a sleep at the switch and the three or four "spoiling snarkies" take over.--------Wonder why there are fewer and fewer topics in discussion????????????????????

Now that we are back into the “work week”, monitoring will probably improve

Reply
Sep 26, 2022 10:48:28   #
petercbrandt Loc: New York City, Manhattan
 
I think Auto is the way to start a newbie. What is photography, a visual language. Capture what your mind instigated. How it turns out will drive you to finesse with the technicalities.

Reply
Sep 26, 2022 11:08:19   #
EJMcD
 
Aperture, Shutter speed, and ISO... learn and understand their relationship. Anyone with average intelligence can and will get more out of their photography with that knowledge. It's not rocket science. IMO beginners should start with a fully adjustable, all manual camera. My first SLR was a Yashica J-P..

Reply
Page <<first <prev 15 of 21 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.