Gene51 wrote:
There is no substitute for stability in a tripod. If by saying you are not a pro you are willing to accept blurry pictures, then buy the $240 tripod and head. Eventually you will come to understand that you just threw away $240, and other than a lesson learned it provided no value to you, since it will never be stable with anything other than a wide angle lens shooting landscapes. It will not stabilize a camera and lens with a viewing angle equal to a 960mm lens. That is not just silly thinking, it is pretty delusional.
You need to look harder, and try and understand the RRS tripod selection guide and the relationship between leg thickness and stability, and why a $240 tripod doesn't thick legs and won't be stable. You will also learn that load carrying capacity has nothing to do with stability. It's only a test to ensure that gravity will not pull you camera to the ground because it is too heavy. Even a $50 Dolica tripod will accomplish that. So if you believe that this is a good way to rate and compare a tripod, you can save yourself $190, and you will only be making a $50 error.
The Gitzo catalog basically says the same thing.
Trust me, if the Desmond was as good as you believe, no pro would bother owning better gear, and just buy a bunch of these - so when they break they can just toss it and unbox a new one. That will never happen.
I am not trying to be a smart ass or give you a hard time - but don't rely on user reviews from totally unqualified people who just got a $240 tripod after upgrading from a $50 one and they think they just got the best thing since sliced bread. They don't know any better, and you would just be a blind person following a group of blind people. The best way is to rent and test for yourself. Or borrow from friends. Or buy and return.
With that being said, I own a Sigma Sport 150-600 - it is noticeably better than the Contemporary, in build quality and image quality. I have owned it since last December, used it daily during fall migration, and I've had it out at least 3-4x a week now that things are heating up again. I have yet to put it on my tripod, a Feisol CT3472.
If I were on a tripod it would have been completely impossible to get this shot of a Great Blue Heron flying over my head.
There is no substitute for stability in a tripod. ... (
show quote)