Gene51 wrote:
Context is everything.
I gave away my massive Bogen 3051 with it's 3047 head - 15 lbs, 2 leg sections which when fully collapsed was 34 inches, or 27" wit the head removed. I used it in my studio when I didn't need the stability of my 250 lb Foba camera stand. It did ok in the studio with relatively short to medium focal length lenses, at lower magnifications. For macro it vibrated too much.
I got rid of it when I started using a DSLR with 300mm and longer lenses. It just was not stable enough. So much for inertia (aka mass) as a criteria for tripod selection.
I was on a limited budget (3 kids in college will do that) but I wanted to do more wildlife photography - especially birds. I had rented an aluminum Gitzo 1500 Tele Studex with 3 section legs and found it to be far superiod to the Bogen - but it still weighed 10 lbs. I then rented a Series 5 carBon and found it just as stable, if not more, when compared to the aluminum - despite the fact it was less then half the weight. So I scoured The classifieds, eBay, Fred Miranda Naturescapes and other active buy/sell websites for over 4 months and none came up for sale. So I bought what I could afford, a series 3 for about $550. It was a beautiful tripod, but, as expected, it was less than stable enough with my 600mmF4. However, it was more stable than the Bogen and weighed a totally manageable 4.1 lbs. While I was close, I had not been able to hit my budget/stabilty/dead weight goals.
It was 2006, and I was running out of options. I sent the tripod back. What was the point of owning an amazing tripod that failed to meet my needs?
I was beginning to hear great things about a new brand out of China - Feisol - so I looked at their top model - the CT-3472. Under 4lbs, thicker legs than the Series 3 Gitzo (so it had to be more stable than the Series 3 I thought), and it had a comparable load capacity 66 lbs vs 55 lbs - in the event I wanted to add some weight for more stability. So I took a chance and ordered one from China. It hit all my criteria - affordability, stability, collapsed size, extended size, build quality. It cost me $540 shipped.
With it's 37mm diameter top leg sections it was in fact more stable than the Series 3's 35mm (as expected), the same weight, and could fit in my carry on bag.
While a comparable Gitzo (Series 4) GT-4543LS will work, it is 1.25 lbs heavier, and currently costs $1000. The Feisol is under $600. So my answer to the original question is- tripods do not have to be expensive to be good. But you need to pick the correct performance criteria - top tube diameter and platform diameter - to match your needs. If you need a tripod for travel with "normal" focal lengths, you needs are quite modest and even a $200 tripod can work. But if you push the stability envelope, you would be throwing money away buying a light-duty tripod for use with long lenses or macro. I use a 2 lb Feisol tripod for travel and backpacking, but it still costs $400. It has a load capacity of 55lb, so if I need to I can always hang my backpack from it, but I find I seldom need to as long as I don't go too crazy with magnification. FWIW, the 2 lb CT-3442 is about as stable as my 15 lb Bogen was.and it has 2x the load capacity. So much for weight, mass, inertia or whatever you want to call it, being everything. It's more complicated than that.
Context is everything. br br I gave away my mass... (
show quote)
Bravo, Gene! I KNEW you would weigh in with the most cogent argument for a very good tripod.
I bought the Feisol, largely on Gene's many explanations and endorsements of good quality tripods. I have a CT-3442 model which is more than adequate for my Fuji X-T2, with grip, and 100-400 lens, which is my largest setup (don't think there are any larger/heavier lenses in the Fuji lineup, yet). The thing is extremely well built. I put a Sirui K-20X ballhead on it (55lbs capacity, fwiw). A rock solid combo in a relatively small package. The whole setup cost $460.
So, you really don't need to spend a bundle on a good tripod, but Gitzo and ReallyRightStuff certainly have the right idea about how to make an excellent tripod.