PNagy wrote:
I see nothing wrong with either of your images, although I predicted when I saw the dual portrait that the vignetting would go under assault. My perspective is that rather than darkening the mood, it focuses the eyes on the interaction of the two people. The scenery shot also has some vignetting added, but this is much more subtle. I like the composition and the contrast. You receive high marks from me, even if that means I am excommunicated by others.
You said exactly what I was thinking. I love both pics as they are.
Everyone has such different tastes that one will always get several different viewpoints. Just go with what YOU like, not necessarily what others like.