NMGal wrote:
I currently have a crop sensor 24mp, a medium format 51mp and have rented a full frame 47mp. Logically, the full frame would be good compromise in terms of resolution and image quality. I generally shoot anything except people. I like them all but would not carry any of them very far. I can’t walk very far. All are a good size and weight. Based on this info, would the full frame do a decent job, all other things being equal? Hope this makes sense.
________________________________________________________________________
I feel your pain, likely most of us have been in a similar position.
Back when I had a 24mp sensor but a more amateur frame a friend convinced me to get a Nikon D300. I did and was horrified in the lackluster performance after all the wonderful things I had read about it and went back to the old camera. After that I moved up to a Nikon D800 36mp sensor and thought I was in heaven until I shot a friends D810 which was much sharper and maybe even a little better dynamic range.
While in Arches summer before last I was shooting with the D810, loving it when I met 3 different photographers, all from Germany and all of them shooting the D850. They all told me I would throw rocks at the D810 if I ever shot the D850. I didn't believe them and imagined I was getting better pictures then they ever would.
Some months later I was at Noah's Arc in Kentucky and again I met some shooters using the D850 and they again shamed me.
Now I'm shooting with a D850 47mp sensor. Friends tell me I should have gone with the Z7 but I will tell you that I don't know how I could get better pictures than what I'm getting. It is hard to get a bad picture, there is so much room in the dynamic range that even poorly exposed shots can be recovered really well. If you are a pixel peeper though you will have to move up to good glass and careful shooting, short exposures will become your friend.
I don't do a lot of portraits except when the grand-kids ask and with 22 of them that happens a lot. Anyway I like birds, flowers and landscapes, my favorite pictures have all been landscapes including a lot of sunsets. With landscapes it's all about lugging it around to a remote area and getting a lot of dynamic range, especially for sunsets.
I suppose a 50 megapixel medium format frame would do a good job but at 47 megapixels I'm nearly there with the D850 so, right now I think I'm where I need to be. I've got a very nice carbon fiber tripod but it isn't as steady as my old aluminum clunker so I take the clunker. When I'm on location I leave the camera case in the car and use one or two lens belt hangers or a fanny pack, a strap a friend gave me that distributes the weight of the camera it's weight isn't a problem and using the tripod as a walking stick makes it's weight not so much of a problem. I'm an old guy who doesn't like to walk but I do like the shots so I walk anyway and complain for a couple days after but that's ok I'm usually sitting in front of PS for a couple days anyway.
The old cameras are gathering dust. I would have never imagined not using the 810 when I got it I thought it was heaven sent but now I leave it at home.
I have found that glass is a very important part of the equation and fortunately once I moved up to full frame and got new glass I haven't had to change while moving up through the Nikon D8xx's to where I am now. Many people will talk of the Nikon holy trinity and while I have some Nikon glass I have not found them to be remarkably different or better than some other brands. I have a cheap Tonika 14mm 2.8 that is wonderful, I got the Tamron 24-70 instead of the Nikon because I found it to have superior vibration control. I got an older F:4 Nikon 70-210 that is unbelievably sharp and the new Tamron 150-600 G2 is rather spectacular at nearly all settings and lengths. While "Nifty Fiftys" are all good I guess I found the old Nikon 50mm 1.4D and the Nikon 50mm 1.8 better than the Nikon 50mm 1.4G. You take a chance whenever you get glass.
The reality is that photos are so much more than just a camera.
I've got a camera I like, I'm happy with it and will be until the next one comes along and blows it out of the water.