Bmac wrote:
Wow, I made it to the end. Guess I might be the last one to kick the horse. What drama, people leaving, no, people not going to C&C anymore, don't post on my thread etc. Hmm....well I think Photoguy was bashed a bit, in a thread in which he didn't ask for critique, which he got anyway, and not constructive critique. Oh well, it happens. Sometimes folks are just so itching to correct a photo that perhaps they don't realize the OP is simply sharing his images. Let's just have a couple of beers and wait for the next episode of "As the Forum Turns." :|
Wow, I made it to the end. Guess I might be the la... (
show quote)
I understand what you are saying but I still don't believe PG was bashed. Quite a few people made positive remarks about photos but he didn't start a new thread about the posters commenting--guess because they were positive. But when a couple (2) made less than glowing comments--he starts a thread complaining about it. So I figure if it is okay to give positive comments, it is okay to give personal opinions.
I know about bashing and what PG got was not bashing. These are some quotes that I received after I asked for help. "When you grow up, maybe just maybe you will understand when people say something to you. Perhaps then too you will have an original thought.Now wipe the snot off your chin, quit getting all indignant and go learn to use a light meter so you don't have to worry about ruining the shots for these people."
As it turned out--the event that I was bashed for taking on and asking for some pointers on lighting it--turned out well. The parents and teachers were thrilled with the girls' pictures. There is a sample on the people photography section at