My first DSLR was a Canon Digital Rebel in 2002. I didn't find it a learning challenge but perhaps that was because I had shot film for nearly 30 years at that point and perhaps more so because I had worked in computers and with digital files for over 15 years at that point. I guess it all depends on what your experience is an how you like to learn. Some are just take it and go shoot and others what to study the manual for a week before they turn it on. My daughter bought a Canon starter kit camera a few years ago and I base some of my observations on what I saw her experience. I guess I am just not a fan of the Creative Modes as I think they can be more of a crutch than just learning the basics of exposure which should serve you well in any shooting situation.
Peterff wrote:
In general I think this is good advice about how one learns - or how different people learn. I agree that creative modes can be confusing from the learning perspective, I don't think I've ever used any of the ones on any of my Canon digital cameras, but that doesn't mean that something like a Canon Rebel kit is a bad thing. Like you I learned when cameras were simpler, I may have even started earlier, with fully manual cameras, but even the most basic Canon DSLRs, mirrorless, bridge, or P&S cameras usually have all the main controls for exposure. I've just looked at my latest Canon DSLR and discovered it doesn't even have creative modes, I've had it for over two months and had to check to find that they weren't there!
For myself, even though I knew what all the features did from prior experience, my first digital camera was quite a learning curve, even though the Canon terminology has remained consistent from around 1976 when the AE-1 was introduced. Any modern camera has many layers of complexity, and in some ways the pro models can be even more confusing given the number of options that can be set, even though they lack the automated creative modes.
At the end of the day, learning the basics of photography, what effect they have upon an image, and how to control them on any camera is the most fundamental thing. This can be done with most modern cameras - not so much smart phones - but the basic principles need to be mastered if one wants to take control of the images created.
An interesting anecdote (to me) from recent history was related to the recent California wildfires. Although San Francisco wasn't affected by the fires directly we had some serious air quality problems, sunsets were spectacular - a bit like the skies over Mordor or from Edvard Munch's 'The Scream' painting - so many people wanted to capture the scene. My wife who was traveling home on public transport ended up with people having to get off the street car. Lots of people immediately got out their smart phones to take pictures of the sky, and the overwhelming (overheard) comment was that the smart phones couldn't capture the image people could see in their minds. Since she is a photographer, some would say a beginner, she just stayed silent while thinking "Yep". She uses her smart phone quite a bit, but was thinking I need my old Nikon SLR or my Canon DSLR for this. She didn't have those of course, did have her smart phone, and just decided not to bother.
In general I think this is good advice about how o... (
show quote)