Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Photo Gallery
Need constructive criticism
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
Feb 7, 2019 07:50:02   #
Wanda Krack Loc: Tennessee, USA
 
The tree on the left is distracting to my eye. If I were facing this scene, I would make an attempt to catch the bridge with nothing between me and the lovely bridge, like walking down the hill and shooting more up, or walking in front of the trees that are showing, or even zooming in between the two trees. Framing an object sometimes works, but the trees become objects themselves instead of a light framing at both sides.

Next two are pleasing compositions, but you might consider bringing more mid-tones out for better details, especially the bridge. I like how you have used leading lines in both of these images.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 07:56:49   #
Ghost45 Loc: Everywhere/ Nowhere
 
Wanda Krack wrote:
The tree on the left is distracting to my eye. If I were facing this scene, I would make an attempt to catch the bridge with nothing between me and the lovely bridge, like walking down the hill and shooting more up, or walking in front of the trees that are showing, or even zooming in between the two trees. Framing an object sometimes works, but the trees become objects themselves instead of a light framing at both sides.

Thank you for your positive feedback.

Next two are pleasing compositions, but you might consider bringing more mid-tones out for better details, especially the bridge. I like how you have used leading lines in both of these images.
The tree on the left is distracting to my eye. If... (show quote)

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 08:52:59   #
Raptor
 
Generally, I like all the pics. The first one with the trees and bridge, looks a bit oversaturated. The closest tree, in the middle, distracts me because it is right in the middle. Would a different shooting position have made it a more compelling shot? Would it be possible (maybe with dodge and burn) to bring out some of the details of the covered bridge interior? That black maw is too big and black.
In all, nice work. Keep shooting and sharing.

Reply
 
 
Feb 7, 2019 09:05:40   #
FiddleMaker Loc: Merrimac, MA
 
Ghost45 wrote:
Looking for comments from the professionals on improvement


Yes, the B&W images are really good. Especially the composition of the photo of the covered bridge. When you get bored, see if you can bring out some detail from inside the bridge where it now is 100% black.

I would think that a skilled photoshop person could remove that ugly light blue drain pipe under the bridge on the 1st photo.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 09:25:03   #
sbohne
 
On the first image I would remove the foreground tree splitting the image. Makes the image much better.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 09:47:45   #
Blaster34 Loc: Florida Treasure Coast
 
Longshadow wrote:
They appear to be level to me, looking at some of the beams in the bridge, and the left side of the larger building in the last. The approach beams to the bridge are on an angle forward, so that is probably what is throwing it off for you.


I really like the photo of the covered bridge but some of it looks tilted or crooked. I agree with you Longshadow, the vertical beams under the roof being vertical but to me the roof, crown under the roof is either tilted or crooked, looks the right eave is slightly higher than the left eave in the photo....and the approach rails (horizontal) on the left near the road seems to be tilted inward. Hard to tell from that angle, maybe just my perspective. Any lens correction used? But then again it just might be a crooked bridge after all this time...

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 10:28:17   #
Bazbo Loc: Lisboa, Portugal
 
Ghost45 wrote:
Looking for comments from the professionals on improvement


First of all, you have a very good eye for composition.

Image 1: Its hard to know exactly what the subject is. The trees are in focus and the bridge is not out of focus enough for it to genuinely blend into the background. When you have a very strong background element like the bridge, throw the aperture wide as it will go so that the background will be more out of focus. The same would be true if you are photographing the bridge and you want your foreground to be out of ficus. If your intent is to have both in sharp focus, then use a tripod and stop down. BTW, I know exactly where this bridge is--I have photographed it myself. It brought back some fond memories even though I ended up in the river hen I tried my hand.

Image 2: Nice composition but I would like to see more detail in the shadow areas.

Image 3: Another nice composition. As another poster said, the image needs to be leveled. Also, there is an element on the left edge of the frame (a fence maybe?) which I find a little distracting. I would either crop it out or "content-aware fill" it away.

I hope this helps.

Reply
 
 
Feb 7, 2019 10:36:02   #
Earnest Botello Loc: Hockley, Texas
 
I am not a professional Ghost, but I have been shooting since the early 70s and I can tell you that these are excellent, especially #1.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 10:52:00   #
Ghost45 Loc: Everywhere/ Nowhere
 
Bazbo wrote:
First of all, you have a very good eye for composition.

Image 1: Its hard to know exactly what the subject is. The trees are in focus and the bridge is not out of focus enough for it to genuinely blend into the background. When you have a very strong background element like the bridge, throw the aperture wide as it will go so that the background will be more out of focus. The same would be true if you are photographing the bridge and you want your foreground to be out of ficus. If your intent is to have both in sharp focus, then use a tripod and stop down. BTW, I know exactly where this bridge is--I have photographed it myself. It brought back some fond memories even though I ended up in the river hen I tried my hand.

Image 2: Nice composition but I would like to see more detail in the shadow areas.

Image 3: Another nice composition. As another poster said, the image needs to be leveled. Also, there is an element on the left edge of the frame (a fence maybe?) which I find a little distracting. I would either crop it out or "content-aware fill" it away.

I hope this helps.
First of all, you have a very good eye for composi... (show quote)


Thank you

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 11:19:34   #
Blair Shaw Jr Loc: Dunnellon,Florida
 
Your B&W images are thrilling and my favorites of the group.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 11:27:06   #
donziska
 
Your shots are good images. On the first one get rid of the two signs and the car and if you can move to the left and get the whole bridge in the screen and trees to the right. The two B&W ones are a bit dark you might lighten them a bit. On the bridge you might back up just a bit and get more lead lines with the road and walk. Don Z.

Reply
 
 
Feb 7, 2019 12:18:33   #
JCam Loc: MD Eastern Shore
 
Longshadow wrote:
The first looks surreal.
Love the two B&W shots.


I also think the first shot is too busy. What's the subject or is it just the mass of colors. Perhaps if it were shot from between the two trees some of the foreground would go away.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 14:18:46   #
Meadwilliam
 
First one. Is it picture of a tree or a bridge. The bridge is certainly more interesting. Always (almost) fill the frame with the important object.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 15:24:11   #
denis.fr
 
it's my choice, Denis



Reply
Feb 7, 2019 16:19:27   #
Harvey Loc: Pioneer, CA
 
Great captures - # 1 is one I would do some PP on - that yellow sign would go as well as either burning the reflection on the drain pipe or cloning out - the car and other metal signs could also use some burning to eliminate/cut their reflection.
#2 nothing could be done to improve this image as no mater what angle one would shoot it those angled beams used for supports throughout the structure will always look "off" to some people
#3 great image - the fence on the left could come further down to the corner or be cut out completely.
JMHO
Harvey

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Photo Gallery
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.