rmalarz wrote:
Well, actually it is, or is it?
Let's get our brains working this morning with this poser. I've seen a number of comments on this site regarding using small f-stops and diffraction. The typical, don't use small apertures because that causes diffraction. So, what is diffraction? Diffraction of light occurs when a light wave passes by a corner or through an opening or slit that is physically the approximate size of, or even smaller than that light's wavelength. I've added the bold to emphasize the size required. So how big are those sizes?
Visible light has a range of wavelengths of 400 - 700 nanometers. Whoa, how big is a nanometer? It's .000000001 meters or .000000039370 inches. So 400 - 700 nanometers is .0000004 - .0000007 meters or .000015748 - .000027559 inches. These dimensions are quite a bit smaller than any apertures we're using with our cameras.
So getting back to our original statement, f/16 is actually equal to f/16. But, that's because f-stops are ratios. What isn't the same is the diameter of the aperture from one lens focal length to another. For example, let's take two lenses, In this case, we'll examine two Schneider-Kreuznach lenses of focal lengths 150mm and 210mm. At f/16 the aperture opening is:
150 - 9.375mm
210 - 13.125mm
Obviously, a large difference in aperture diameters, but the same f-stop. However, neither is close to the wavelength range of visible light.
Since diffraction occurs as stated above, neither of these measurements are close to the dimensions required to meet the above conditions. So, how would light know which lens it's passing through? Oh, and if you want to make an issue of the "passing by a corner", well, that corner exists at every f-stop, other than perhaps the greatest opening.
The conclusion of this could be that we're parroting some misinformation, making a blanket statement that doesn't cover all situations, or we may be concerning ourselves needlessly. If diffraction does occur, is it observable in our photographs?
--Bob
Well, actually it is, or is it? br br Let's get o... (
show quote)
For those of us with experience with large format, we all know that f16 or 22 is no problem with these larger formats even if we don't fully understand why. However, probably 99% or more of the f stop discussions on this site are in reference to "full frame" or smaller digital cameras which certainly can be affected by f stops higher than f11 or 16.