BHC wrote:
Yes, a very odd topic, but one that has me baffled.
HYPOTHETICALLY, XYZ is a business from which I have bought thousands of dollars worth of equipment over a long period. Recently, for whatever reason, there have been whispers, rumors and even court actions regarding questionable practices on their part, but I have never encountered such practices.
Last week, I ordered camera #12345 from the used camera department. The camera was advertised as being in condition 10. Several days later, I received an email from the company saying they could not find camera #12345, even though their records show they had it. They said they could sell me a new camera at a small discount or they could sell me used camera #67890 with a lower condition rating at a slightly lower price. Given no other options, I ordered camera #67890; I was told it would be here Wednesday. Now it's Friday; my camera is finally out for delivery (I hope!). BUT, today I called the warehouse. Yes, they do have camera #12345 in stock.
Simple question... Was I the victim of a bait-and-switch?
I am NOT accusing XYZ of employing this tactic regularly. My attorney, a golfing buddy, says it appears that I was. I cannot believe that a company I have done business with for years would stoop so low.
I would appreciate your feedback on this HYPOTHETICAL situation. Thank you.
Yes, a very odd topic, but one that has me baffled... (
show quote)
In cases like these, perhaps it takes a moment to "walk in t'other guy's shoes." While I can guess the vendor you're referring to, any used equipment inventory is a challenge to keep up to date and accurate. (Versus new inventory in boxes and bar codes, and invoices to cross check, and Computerized inventory software packages available for sale developed by professionals.)
A Used equipment inventory is a collection of loose equipment, accessories etc. They get received, graded, inventories and placed on in a "location." Logging them in and out of the location is a cute trick and one that is easily messed up. (Think of WHY the Librarian makes you put the books you took off the stacks onto the replacement cart, so STAFF, and NOT YOU, replaces to books correctly.
I can think of a few scenarios in a high volume business where item A, almost identical to Item B, may be off the shelf (and off the inventory lookup) and where Item B might be a suitable offering. Then, circumstances find that Item A was returned to its proper spot physically and digitally in time for a subsequent phone call. Manual systems, even computer augmented, are prone to delays and errors.
Since, from your post I didn't get that the dollar differences were very great. The new offer at ANY discount is an accommodation, in my mind. I didn't get the impression that there was any misrepresentation involved.
Since the suspected vendor, and the two others it may also be, offer a generous no questions asked return policy, that you KNOW is good because you're a long time customer, I can't see how this falls into Bait and Switch. I suggest you ask your attorney friend how he would pursue a case in which the seller says by policy, "OK, you're not happy, send it back for a complete refund after you get to examine it at your home or business for 10 or more days---plus a warranty." What's you're downside--or as the Attorneys say, damages?
As a Native New Yorker (although an escapee for over 50 years) I can tell you that it is never good practice to form an opinion or more importantly base business and money transactions on opinions formed about legal disputes, like the ones I'm guessing are on labor practices, that are being litigated in the Press--especially the NY Press.
Do the deal, DON'T do the deal, That's up to you and your"gut." But projecting ill motives on a long established business, where you have a relationship, and if my suspicions are correct have a fellow UHH member who acts in Ombudsman role, is a step too far. Let's leave the projections to the Camera Clubs, Movies and Politicians.
I mean this constructively. In today's world, it is easy to think you're being taken advantage of. It happens all the time. I think you're dealing with a good business be it any one of the Big 3 in NY. If you get the jitters easily, then perhaps, buying used equipment isn't for you, at least not remotely. The most important thing is for you to be comfortable with your purchase, be it a genuine unopened box of Chocolates, or an expensive camera, used or new.
Give yourself a break, use your resources and do transactions in ways where you are comfortable.
C