Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
SD card failure (survey kinda sorta...!)
Page <<first <prev 6 of 8 next> last>>
Jun 27, 2014 13:36:28   #
JD750 Loc: SoCal
 
Tea8 wrote:
Once. Last month actually. On my first ever paid shoot. <snip>...... Speaking of which I need to go and order me a couple of extra cards to have around now. I should probably pull myself away from here and go do that, but I just have so much fun here sometimes.


You went on a paid shoot with one flash card?

Yes it's time to buy another card(s) before doing anymore paid work.

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 13:57:01   #
rob s Loc: La Mesa, CA
 
Brandmic wrote:
Only problem was with two different Pny cards (both 16gb). Found out later their had previous issues with them. Never with lexar or sandisk.

This is why during holidays you usually see Pny cards on sale. That's when I bought these that failed.


Ironically I use 16, 32 and 64GB PNY Elite Performance SDHC cards and have never had a failure (so far). However, the only failures I've had were from from Lexar - 2 different 8GB cards went bad and images were not recoverable. Exactly the opposite of your experience.

Different makes of cards all go on sale periodically so I don't think you can read too much into this - I always price shop mine and buy when a deal presents itself.

I've also been well pleased with the Delkin CF cards - usually very competitively priced at B and H and Adorama.

Card readers are a completely different issue. Those I've owned have been variable in their reliability and make and cost don't seem to make a difference. Except for the $##&^ Lexar cards all the other cards I've owned have always uploaded flawlessly from my various Canons, using a USB cable.

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 15:11:10   #
weberwest Loc: Ferndale WA
 
Ranjan wrote:
Web-Pundits generally recommend that we should be using smaller (say 4 or 8 GB) cards so that in case of a card-failure, we cut our losses!

How often is it that you have had a reasonably reputable card (e.g., Sandisk, Lexar, Panasonic, etc) fail on you? In the past 10 years, I have used many different SDHC and SDXC cards with zero failure rate. I am not a power-user of course, but generally upload images by pulling out the card and inserting into the card-readers in computers etc because the transfer is way faster than using the camera to computer (USB 1 or 2)!

The single instance where I have lost images was when using a Lexar compact flash card years ago, and even then it was probably not card-failure, because I reformatted and then continued to use the card flawlessly for years! Oh, incidentally, that was probably the last time I ever did a camera to computer transfer. I strongly suspect that that was the culprit and not the card! Never had a problem since that time.

What has been your experience like...?

Thanks,

R.
Web-Pundits generally recommend that we should be ... (show quote)



With my D90 and only shooting JPEG fine, I used 4 and 8 GB cards for that very reason: fear of failure or loss. Now that I mainly use my new D610 and started to shoot Raw + JPEG fine, I bought myself 10 32 GB cards (we do a lot of extended travels) and feel confident with these, of course I back them up to my notebook for security, but keep the original for final direct loading to my desk top comuter. I mainly use SanDisk but do have a few Transcend cards as well, never had a failure thus far.

Reply
 
 
Jun 27, 2014 16:00:28   #
Brandmic Loc: Alabama
 
There is a good article about memory cards on "photography talk" but this is twice I've tried to post from their site and UHH has blocked the post?

It's "6 ways to protect your memory cards". I don't know why they always block this because there is a lot of good info there ??

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 16:03:38   #
Brandmic Loc: Alabama
 
Here is a copy of the content of article

1 Always format the card as soon as you buy it

Most memory cards are formatted before they leave the factory, but that doesn’t mean they are ready for optimal use. The best way to format a card is inside your camera (and not in your computer) because that’s where it will be doing most of the work. The card needs to be in tune with the camera’s file system.

2 Safe storage

The most vulnerable parts of a memory card are its contacts. Make sure to always protect them. Even the smallest grain of dust can cause problems. They are usually packed in small plastic cases. Those are pretty good options for keeping the cards safe, however, the best recommendation are card wallets and special cases.

3 Try to use one card with one camera only

Data corruption can easily occur if you use the same card in two or more different cameras. Even if they are made by the same manufacturer, the file writing algorithms could be different and that could ultimately lead to data loss.

4 Don’t delete. Format.

Deleting all the files from a card is one thing, formatting, while having the same effect, is another. Basically, when you format a memory card, you restart its use with without having the risk of previous errors.

5 Multiple cards are always better than one, large capacity card.

The temptation to buy a single, high capacity card is understandable. After all, it does seem logical to buy a single 64 or 128GB card instead of many 16 or 32GB memories. However, some people just aren’t fortunate enough, and that single, high capacity card they have postponed to empty for some time is the one that breaks without any warnings and thousands of photos are lost. It’s a gamble in my book. I know it’s not fun to change the card during a busy shoot or a wedding, but it beats losing an entire day’s work and possibly a client.

6 Don’t use cheap card readers

If you’re using a quality memory card (and you should) make sure not to get cheap on the reader. All the precautions in the world won’t be enough if you use a low quality reader, because it can cause damage to data or even the card itself. The best option is using a card reader made by the same manufacturer that produced the card.

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 16:03:54   #
JD750 Loc: SoCal
 
Brandmic wrote:
There is a good article about memory cards on "photography talk" but this is twice I've tried to post from their site and UHH has blocked the post?

It's "6 ways to protect your memory cards". I don't know why they always block this because there is a lot of good info there ??


There is a "links" section on the home page for posting links to commercial sites.

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 16:08:22   #
Tea8 Loc: Where the wind comes sweeping down the plain.
 
jd7000 wrote:
You went on a paid shoot with one flash card?

Yes it's time to buy another card(s) before doing anymore paid work.


No I didn't go to a paid shoot with one card. (I didn't buy a DSLR last week and decide to hang sign over my doorway yesterday.) There were several in my bag, but as I stated every indication I had while on the shoot was that it was fine. I looked at the photos on the card during and right after the shoot and on my screen they were fine. It wasn't until I transferred them to my computer that I noticed the ones that were messed up.

Reply
 
 
Jun 27, 2014 16:17:40   #
coco1964 Loc: Winsted Mn
 
Use Sandisk Extreme Pro 16gig and have never had one fail since I've been shooting digital........

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 17:01:18   #
sshinn1 Loc: Phoenix
 
jd7000 wrote:
It's easy to do.

When taking a card out of a camera, I leave the card slot door on the camera open, as a reminder that a card has been removed.


Good idea - but for me, I have the twin terrors running around (my 2 and 4 year old boys), so when I take out the card to down load the camera goes straight back in the bag to avoid any "curiosity accidents" while I'm not looking

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 18:43:54   #
Ranjan Loc: Currently Cyber-Nation!
 
RICARDOOO wrote:
I wish the 2 individual slots were individually controlable when it comes to deleting an image


Which camera/model...?

Reply
Jun 27, 2014 21:09:36   #
JC56 Loc: Lake St.Louis mo.
 
I prefer SanDisk cards.. I have never had a card crash and I don't buy them on eBay

Reply
 
 
Jun 27, 2014 21:36:03   #
wolfd Loc: Vancouver, Canada
 
Never.
I have even accidentally dropped my Canon G12 in the salt chuck. The camera was toast but all the images on the 16gb SD card were safe & sound.

Reply
Jun 28, 2014 02:07:36   #
BHC Loc: Strawberry Valley, JF, USA
 
Someone just emailed the following hints to me; while the list is not complete, it's a pretty good start:

1. Always format the card as soon as you buy it

The best way to format a card is inside your camera, not in your computer).

2. Safe storage

New cards are usually packed in small plastic cases. Those are good options for keeping the cards safe, however, the best protection is afforded by card wallets and special cases.

3. Try to use one card with one camera only

Even if the cameras and cards are made by the same manufacturer, the transfer algorithms could be different and lead to data loss.

4. Don’t delete images; format the whole card.

Deleting all the files from a card is one thing, formatting, while having the same effect, is another. Basically, when you format a memory card, you restart its use with without having the risk of previous errors.

5. Multiple medium capacity cards are always better than one large capacity card.

If that single, high capacity card you have neglected to empty for some time breaks without any warnings, hundreds of photos can be lost.

6. Don’t use cheap card readers

The best option is using a card reader made by the same manufacturer that produced the card.

Reply
Jun 28, 2014 02:27:39   #
Brandmic Loc: Alabama
 
Mogul wrote:
Someone just emailed the following hints to me; while the list is not complete, it's a pretty good start:

1. Always format the card as soon as you buy it

The best way to format a card is inside your camera, not in your computer).

2. Safe storage

New cards are usually packed in small plastic cases. Those are good options for keeping the cards safe, however, the best protection is afforded by card wallets and special cases.

3. Try to use one card with one camera only

Even if the cameras and cards are made by the same manufacturer, the transfer algorithms could be different and lead to data loss.

4. Don’t delete images; format the whole card.

Deleting all the files from a card is one thing, formatting, while having the same effect, is another. Basically, when you format a memory card, you restart its use with without having the risk of previous errors.

5. Multiple medium capacity cards are always better than one large capacity card.

If that single, high capacity card you have neglected to empty for some time breaks without any warnings, hundreds of photos can be lost.

6. Don’t use cheap card readers

The best option is using a card reader made by the same manufacturer that produced the card.
Someone just emailed the following hints to me; wh... (show quote)


This is what I had posted above.

Reply
Jun 28, 2014 02:35:17   #
BHC Loc: Strawberry Valley, JF, USA
 
Brandmic wrote:
This is what I had posted above.

Sorry, I didn't notice yours. Mine appears to be an edited version of yours. It's strange how you post one and I get an email from a friend (not a UHH member) with almost identical content. I had mentioned some solutions to concerns he had about SD cards, and he did some research on his own.

EDIT: In retrospect, the duplication is serendipitous. I see you posted your list 10 hours ago, but I had not read the thread in the last 12 hours.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 6 of 8 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.