Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Shouldn't I "calibrate" my monitor so that it looks like my printer's output?
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
Nov 28, 2011 10:04:37   #
POVDOV
 
Good luck with your calibrations. I have found that spyder pro and the icc profiles of the papers I use to give me good results. povdov

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 10:14:51   #
ntonkin Loc: western Upper Peninusla of Michigan
 
I would caution all to make sure their monitor can be calibrated with the devices offered for the purpose. I bought a Colormunki for $170 and after much angst and calling the manufacturer they admitted that the thing dosen't work with plasma monitors. Even though their advertising claims that it works with ALL technologies, In fact, it will NOT work with all technologies - and B&H will not take it back because I don't have the original packaging.

If you buy such a device, make absolutely sure that it works properly before you thow away the packaging.

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 10:24:10   #
photocat Loc: Atlanta, Ga
 
I know of several people who have "trained " their eye to judge the difference between the monitor and the printer.

THey have lots of years in the darkroom and experience and make 100's of test prints.

So it can be done, it will depend on how much time, energy and money one wants to spend.

Reply
Check out Black and White Photography section of our forum.
Nov 28, 2011 10:25:53   #
donnahde Loc: Newark, DE
 
I use Costco, too, but have a difficult time getting my prints to match what I see on my monitor. I got the ICC profile for my local Costco but have no idea how to use that profile. I have Elements 9, LR3 and Picasa but can't find anywhere in any of those programs to "install" that profile. Can anyone help?

abc1234 wrote:
This is ultimately a losing battle. Even if you use the same color model for monitor, print and editing software, and printer, you are using different technologies. Like comparing apples and oranges. Especially if you are using a cmyk printer.

This was a big factor to give up printing my own small prints. For photographic quality, I go to Costco. For prints up to 60" wide, I use my Mimaki JV3 at work.

Good luck and do not drive yourself crazy over this.

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 10:42:19   #
alaskanfrog Loc: Alaska
 
charlessmall18 wrote:
I suppose everyone has noticed that what you see on your computer monitor often does not look much like what comes out of your printer. So far the expert advice i have seen boils down to "calibrate your monitor." By "calibrate," I take it that the experts mean my monitor should display images hewing as closely as possible to the MS sRGB or Adobe "color spaces." I admit I don't know anything about color spaces but this advice seems off the mark to me. If I am manipulating colors on my monitor by eye, shouldn't my monitor be "calibrated" such that its colors look as much as possible like what my printer will output? Or if I am stuck with a "properly calibrated" monitor, does anyone have any tips about what to do with respect to feedback into Photoshop/GIMP to optimize or improve an image after I see a less than optimal printout? There are lots of things I can do the the colors in an image but which ones and by how much? The only hint I heard along this line was to "move the histogram to the right." [!?]
I suppose everyone has noticed that what you see o... (show quote)


for the best results in printing, it's actually a good idea for you to set your printer preferences, rather than calibrate your monitor. Monitor calibration is a good idea so that your photos look like what your camera saw when you shot the image.

Setting your printer preferences to "Color Match" the monitor offers the best solution to resolving most, but not all color printing issues. Setting your printing preferences to RGB color value, Adobe color packer or monitor calibration allows the printer to see what is available and chooses your preferences for color printing. Each time you select print by either selecting "control-P" or scrolling down from "File" to Print in the drop down menu, a popup window appears. There are numerous selections to choose from for your printer settings, including color matching for your monitor, quality and speed, papery type, and etc..

When working with photos, you are actually working with a minimum of 4 different color technologies; the computer, the monitor, the camera and the printer. All 4 of these work in tandem to create a printed picture. First, you shoot a photo with your camera, next, you load the photo into your computer, followed by editing, and lastly printing. That's the very basic of how this works.

Calibrating your monitor will assist you in creating the photo you took with your camera. Editing allows you to make adjustments to your photo so that it closely matches what you saw. First, your monitor must be calibrated as best as possible to achieve the best possible picture on the monitor. Once calibrated properly, then the printer can be set to print what is on the monitor by using the popup window that appears, asking what you want to do and how you want the printer to behave when it prints.

All this said, one of the underlying weak links of all this for color values, are the inks. All inkjet printers use a water based ink and most are actually vegetable, nontoxic inks. However, the weakness and problems are with the inks themselves and not actually the printers. This changes again for color office, high volume printers, including workstation printers such as a "Bizhub, or Laser Printer." Different companies use different formulas for their inks. Since there are dozens and even, hundreds of different printers on the market, the margin for error in ink colors is huge. Even though a manufacturer follows specific guidelines for mixing batches of ink, there will inevitably be variations in the colors from one batch to the next. Most are so minute you would never be able to detect the differences until you actually start printing.

This can be and really is a complex topic to discuss. Knowing how to calibrate your monitor is very important in photography. Knowing how to set your print preferences in your printer is equally important, so that you always get the most consistent printouts of your photos. Read about setting the printer to "Color Match" your monitor so that most color print issues are minimized. Great discussion topic and thanks. Good luck...

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 10:55:24   #
silver Loc: Santa Monica Ca.
 
charlessmall18 wrote:
I suppose everyone has noticed that what you see on your computer monitor often does not look much like what comes out of your printer. So far the expert advice i have seen boils down to "calibrate your monitor." By "calibrate," I take it that the experts mean my monitor should display images hewing as closely as possible to the MS sRGB or Adobe "color spaces." I admit I don't know anything about color spaces but this advice seems off the mark to me. If I am manipulating colors on my monitor by eye, shouldn't my monitor be "calibrated" such that its colors look as much as possible like what my printer will output? Or if I am stuck with a "properly calibrated" monitor, does anyone have any tips about what to do with respect to feedback into Photoshop/GIMP to optimize or improve an image after I see a less than optimal printout? There are lots of things I can do the the colors in an image but which ones and by how much? The only hint I heard along this line was to "move the histogram to the right." [!?]
I suppose everyone has noticed that what you see o... (show quote)


The correct procedure is to first calibrate the monitor. By doing this your monitor has a correct color gamut that will be correct. This has nothing to do with color space, it only matches your color to an industry standard. There is no such thing as calibrating a printer, what is done is you can design profiles for whatever paper you want to print on. It may not make sense but every paper you use will print differently. Making profiles is easy with the right set up. I use a device called the Colormonki. This device allows me to calibrate my monitor and it also allows me to create paper profiles. The unit is easy to use and it is very effective. The only problem is the Colormonki is expensive, around $375.00. When you consider how much paper you use trying to get good color prints that this device saves you in the long run its a good deal. I can now calibrate my monitor and create my own profiles easily and in most instances I do one small test print and then I am ready to do final prints. You can use the "canned" profiles that are supplied by paper manufacturers but in most instances these profiles are not as good as the profiles that you can make your self in a custom way for your system. I did have a minor problem when I first got the Colormonki but a call to Xrite solved the problem, they are very helpful. Calling them first before you purchase one and asking about compatibility with your system is a good idea. I am a custom digital printer and I have been doing this for quite a while.

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 10:55:41   #
CAM1017 Loc: Chiloquin, Oregon
 
You can download free monitor calibration programs from the web. Try entering " monitor calibration". something will come up. That said, after calibration, you may still notice a difference between your monitor and the printer. When I have reached this point I have experimented to find the adjustments I needed to make in my editing program to give me the output I wanted from my printer. A lot of the color space stuff (etc.) that people talk about is above my head. Just doing a little experimenting a wasting a few prints works for me.

Reply
Check out The Dynamics of Photographic Lighting section of our forum.
Nov 28, 2011 11:36:58   #
bulach
 
A friend of mine uses a software product called Qimage Ultimate and it sells for around $90. He says the software has full color managment control including the paper, monitor and printer. He says he is really satisfied with the product. I saw some of his prints and they look pretty darn good. I never researched the product so I do not know its capabilities or how it functions. We have a local photography shop in town that makes prints. That is where I have my prints made. It is more expensive but very satisfying.
Bulach

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 11:49:55   #
Ronny Loc: Netherlands
 
steve_stoneblossom wrote:
I am by no means an expert in this, but I do not believe you should be adjusting your monitor to match your printer. While monitors work with RGB or sRGB color space (Red, Green, Blue- for the colors of the individual pixels), your printer is working with CMYK color space (Cyan, Magenta, Yellow and Key (for black), for the colors of ink or toner). In Photoshop you can change the color space used to save your file by clicking on "image" and then "mode" and choose CMYK. You may notice a slight change on your monitor; in my experience most often in blues and some loss in contrast. Calibrate your monitor for monitors, as BBNC suggests. Your printer is a separate issue.
I am by no means an expert in this, but I do not b... (show quote)


What if you do not use Photoshop?

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 11:51:53   #
nikonshooter Loc: Spartanburg, South Carolina
 
Ronny wrote:
steve_stoneblossom wrote:
I am by no means an expert in this, but I do not believe you should be adjusting your monitor to match your printer. While monitors work with RGB or sRGB color space (Red, Green, Blue- for the colors of the individual pixels), your printer is working with CMYK color space (Cyan, Magenta, Yellow and Key (for black), for the colors of ink or toner). In Photoshop you can change the color space used to save your file by clicking on "image" and then "mode" and choose CMYK. You may notice a slight change on your monitor; in my experience most often in blues and some loss in contrast. Calibrate your monitor for monitors, as BBNC suggests. Your printer is a separate issue.
I am by no means an expert in this, but I do not b... (show quote)


What if you do not use Photoshop?
quote=steve_stoneblossom I am by no means an expe... (show quote)


Aperture, Elements, NX2 .....most post software will let you change your color space.....but I would never convert to CYMK without intentions of converting back to either Adobe 98 for printing, and Adobe Srgb for web. RGB converts directly to CYM in the printer....also there Black is added. RGB emits colors while the CMY filters subtracts color and has the affect of absorbing or reflecting ink. i

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 12:13:09   #
pebo111 Loc: Eastern Oregon (Pendleton)
 
To help a little I hope. I have two monitors and I have to adjust them ever so often One adjusts fine the othere not so much. but I only need one to be very close.

I use a tool called HUEY PRO. It walks you threw different steps to set up your monitor. I have used it for 5 years and like it.

Good luck Pebo111

Reply
Check out Wedding Photography section of our forum.
Nov 28, 2011 12:23:04   #
photocat Loc: Atlanta, Ga
 
I have been using Qimage for my printing rip for years,

It will let you decide to use the printer or the software for color control. You can print in sRGB or RGB color space, you can download ICC profiles and use this as well.

I believe they still have a trial download and I would suggest giving it a try.

It does amazing other things .

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 13:16:10   #
rborud Loc: Minnesota
 
Having gone through the hell of calibration and never being totally satisfied with my result, an epiphany for me happened when with the need for a new monitor became apparent. I happened into a Micro-center and found a Gateway that looked nice and was priced well, and I bought it. Started down the same road to calibration HELL, and discovered in the box an unasumeing CD marked Easy Tune, and thought what is this. Loaded it, ran it (which was easy and kind of fun) and discovered if I defaulted my printers software, all seemed to match. I also discovered the CD was specific to Gateway monitors alas. I do not have any need to match anyone else, so with this I became free of the angst of calibration. I gave away several calibrators I had a love/hate relationship with.
This may help someone to crawl out of this sometime mess.

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 13:27:47   #
rborud Loc: Minnesota
 
Sorry on my comments I used the name Easy Tune, it should have been Eztune.

Reply
Nov 28, 2011 13:38:39   #
photocat Loc: Atlanta, Ga
 
ry here for some info on color space, calibration and a ton of other goodies

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/tutorials

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Check out Smartphone Photography section of our forum.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.