dustie
Loc: Nose to the grindstone
jerryc41 wrote:
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling me that I'm on the list of potential jurors. I filled out the lengthy form online, and I'll see what happens. They know my date of birth, so they know I'm almost 80, if that makes any difference.
I was called about thirty years ago, and I was looking forward to being on a jury, but I was dismissed. My son was on a grand jury, and he found that very interesting. He was surprised that the drug dealers were so well educated and so well spoken.
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling ... (
show quote)
Here is an interesting article that seemingly applies specifically to New York jury matters.
I suppose a certain amount of it is fairly universally applicable to other U.S. states, as well.
https://www.oginski-law.com/library/jury-selection-can-i-excuse-jurors-if-i-dont-like-them-.cfm
jerryc41 wrote:
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling me that I'm on the list of potential jurors. I filled out the lengthy form online, and I'll see what happens. They know my date of birth, so they know I'm almost 80, if that makes any difference.
I was called about thirty years ago, and I was looking forward to being on a jury, but I was dismissed. My son was on a grand jury, and he found that very interesting. He was surprised that the drug dealers were so well educated and so well spoken.
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling ... (
show quote)
If you are trying to get out of jury duty just fill out the questionnaire and be sure to mention that you would be an excellent juror because you can tell if someone is innocent or guilty just by looking at them.
jerryc41 wrote:
I can imagine a TV comedy sketch with a room full of 80-year-old jurors. I'm laughing already. 🤣
Lord have mercy! You sound just like me. Does your imagination always run toward something funny? Mine does more often than I admit.
Jimmy T wrote:
... or a cell phone you couldn't check it
Wow. In LA, we can bring cell-phones and laptops (but not the little knife on my keychain).
jerryc41 wrote:
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling me that I'm on the list of potential jurors. I filled out the lengthy form online, and I'll see what happens. They know my date of birth, so they know I'm almost 80, if that makes any difference.
I was called about thirty years ago, and I was looking forward to being on a jury, but I was dismissed. My son was on a grand jury, and he found that very interesting. He was surprised that the drug dealers were so well educated and so well spoken.
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling ... (
show quote)
A long-long-long time ago I was called down & sat in a room for a week mostly watched tv & twice a day would get called to a courtroom for juror selection & never picked. Then years later called again & the same thing but in a court room for four days & people would come up with excuse why they couldn't be there. On the fourth day & running low on jurors to pick the judge stopped letting people of the hook because he was running out of potential jurors to choose from. I was picked for a case & the next day we came in for a couple of hours to hear about the case & the next Tuesday we judged it. The defendant was innocent. Then a few years later had to go down again for possible selection which if picked would be a different case every Wednesdays for sixteen weeks. By 11 am they had the jurors picked & I was let go (about 16 years ago) & never received another notice.
llamb
Loc: Northeast Ohio
Thirty years ago I was an alternate in a three-way personal claim case involving heirs and a religious sect. We heard the three side's opening statements and adjourned for lunch. Before we left, the judge gave us instructions not to discuss the case amongst ourselves or with anyone else. Upon returning we were ordered to a separate room and left there for and hour or so. We were then led back to the jury box and the judge began to berate us for failing to abide to his instructions. After ten minutes of admonishment - he was fuming at us, he told us what had happened. At a lunchroom a juror witnessed one of the other jurors and one of the claimants having lunch together and discussing the case! She reported it to the bailiff and writs hit the fan! Why the judge yelled at all of us confused and angered me for a couple of reasons; I did do anything wrong, and the trial was really interesting. We were dismissed from further jury duty and I have always wondered what the final outcome was.
~Lee
John N
Loc: HP14 3QF Stokenchurch, UK
Did Jury service just after I turned 18 (U.K.). Car theft. Older lady on the Jury immediatley hung out the accussed to dry. Eyes were to close together she said. We all agreed guilty (but not on the spacing of his eyes) and returned to the Courtroom where the Judge read out a list of previous offences as long as my arm.
I found it very enlightening, and as a bonus it doubled my apprentice pay at the time.
dustie
Loc: Nose to the grindstone
John N wrote:
Older lady on the Jury immediatley hung out the accussed to dry. Eyes were to close together she said.
😲 🤔
All beady-eyed eagles must be guilty, all cows must be innocent.
Nassau County kept sending jury duty notices to a daughter who moved out of state 10 years ago.
I'd sent them back for years and finally called them.
"She moved,
Can you prove it?
Come and look for yourself"
They finally stopped
I thought that over 70 , you can tell them to get lost .
Morry
Loc: Palm Springs, CA
If one has memory problems . . . that is usually a valid reason not to do jury duty.
fantom wrote:
If you are trying to get out of jury duty just fill out the questionnaire and be sure to mention that you would be an excellent juror because you can tell if someone is innocent or guilty just by looking at them.
You could also tell them that if the defendant got this far in the system, he must be guilty.
jerryc41 wrote:
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling me that I'm on the list of potential jurors. I filled out the lengthy form online, and I'll see what happens. They know my date of birth, so they know I'm almost 80, if that makes any difference.
I was called about thirty years ago, and I was looking forward to being on a jury, but I was dismissed. My son was on a grand jury, and he found that very interesting. He was surprised that the drug dealers were so well educated and so well spoken.
I received a notice from the County Clerk telling ... (
show quote)
I was called for jury duty once and was accepted. My trial was really bizarre involving a children's baseball game where one parent was accused of killing another in an argument about a play on the field. One of the parents involved got in a fight with one of the coaches and was knocked unconscious and died later in the hospital. He had a special condition affecting his ears that lead to his death.
When the trial began, the first witness for the prosecution (yes prosecution) said someone other than the defendant did it. No explanation offered. After the trial, the first duty of the jury is to elect a foreman. I was elected unanimously because, during the trial, I raised my hand and asked a question about a conference the judge, prosecutor and defense attorney just had at the bench. Was told it was a discussion on technicality on how to proceed. We ended up a hung jury and were instructed to continue to meet until we resolved it. Our jury has asked the judge several questions during our deliberation to clarify some issues, but we received nebulous answers. We finally asked for a definition of what reasonable doubt meant. The answer to that question resolved the hung jury and we reached a manslaughter verdict.
I suppose some of the following might be due to specific courts or maybe just an agreement between prosecution and defense. I thought that the jury would get an opportunity to see the evidence presented during the trial. We were informed by the bailiff that we would not be able to see it. I asked the bailiff if we could take notes during the trial for later reference and he had to ask the judge. We were told we could but only on the condition that the notes would be collected at the end of each day.
The trial lasted over 3 weeks and one of the jurors had vacation plans involving air travel with tickets that could not be cancelled. She told the judge (via the bailiff) that she was going to leave if the trial was not over. She was informed that if she tried to leave, she would be arrested and jailed for contempt of court.
All in all, lots of drama in and out of the courtroom. The prosecutor talked to the jury after the trial and told us that he knew he wasn't going to get the verdict he wanted after we asked about reasonable doubt but told us we reached a just verdict. It was the only time I was ever called.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.