Both are good but have a slightly different message, each appealling to a different aesthetic point of view, as reflected in the nearly balanced responses. Degustibus non disputum est!
srt101fan wrote:
I feel the same way.
Likewise - I'm a big fan of B&W but the soft pastels tell a better story for this image. Great composition.
I guess I will go with the color, I can't tell what he is doing in either.
B&W. Out of curiosity what is he doing.
I would go with the colour. A couple of other points to think about. You appear to have some blown highlights that in my view catch the eye. A border around the black image may also help.
I think the B &W has more impact
AndyT
Loc: Hampstead, New Hampshire
A couple people asked what is he doing? He is a jewelry repair man.
Definitely color...what's the story in black and white? And I freely admit that I am very biased...most of the time on here if I open a black and white I close it before it loads. Life is in color!
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.