Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
No Trespassing
Page <<first <prev 15 of 16 next>
Mar 22, 2020 14:12:36   #
Mr Bill 2011 Loc: southern Indiana
 
jrm21 wrote:
I agree. My response was in reference to the quoted comment (from the OP)which spoke to being a few feet off the road. Merely wanted to point out that a few feet of safe distance off the road is almost always still "public road" and thus, not what this topic turned into.

In the case of the text I quoted, I also wonder where the car would be parked if there is little or no shoulder? Would the person be driving onto what they thought to be private land?


or if the road had little or no shoulder and the driver pulled partially on to the shoulder with part of the car still on the driving surface, I can see a cop giving him a ticket for impeding traffic, even if it is a dead end road with little traffic. It's one thing to have a flat or a break down and have the car sticking into the roadway; it's something else to stop with part of the car on the road if all you want to do is take a picture. That's where common sense comes in.

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 14:24:00   #
insman1132 Loc: Southwest Florida
 
dennis2146 wrote:
Generally speaking the sign is on the boundary of the area not to be crossed into.

Dennis


Thanks, Dennis. I was also told that unless there is at least one strand of fencing erected the sign has no validity? Any idea if that is correct?

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 14:32:42   #
dennis2146 Loc: Eastern Idaho
 
Steve V wrote:
Dennis,

Not entitled here. The petroleum pipeline cut and Ukrainian church field that I walk do not have any "No Trespassing" signs. The priests see me there often and have never said anything There is a "No Loitering" and a "No Fishing" sign by the creek but that in all in the way of signage. I have never trespassed on signed private property nor would I. I will admit to crossing the line on government property (the one in the image ). By gently I meant doing no harm and leaving no trace.

But after reading this thread I intend to ask the church permission to photograph on their property. That said I have evidence that poaching took place on the property. I photographed a tree stand, a bait station and a gut pile on the property. I checked the state regulations and it is illegal to take to take deer out of season even on private property. By the date a deer was taken out of season. I think the bait station is illegal too. When I ask for permission should I tell them about the poaching too? Maybe they already know. Conflicted here on that. What do you think?

By the way I think the fox were happy about the gut pile as it was gone the next day.

Thanks,

Steve
Dennis, br br Not entitled here. The petroleum pi... (show quote)


I am talking about the government property.

Dennis

Reply
 
 
Mar 22, 2020 14:34:47   #
Mr Bill 2011 Loc: southern Indiana
 
cameraf4 wrote:
jrm, your avatar does not tell us where you live. If you live in PA (for instance) you would know that many roads there have no shoulder per se that will accommodate a parked car. However, as others have pointed out, the width of a state road extends generally several feet off the pavement to allow for road maintenance. While driving around PA hunting the wooden covered bridges (the most of any state) many state-printed brochures describe, there is often "little or no shoulder" between the pavement and a ditch. In recent years (decades really) I shy away from properties where a No Trespass sign is displayed, for some of the reasons others have posted. However, when I bought my first camera more than 40 years ago, I admit that I would (on occasion) step a little bit more than those "several feet" off the road for a shot, provided that no one else was in sight and the area was not so muddy as to leave a trace of my passing.

These days, for sure, I DO NOT advocate such behavior, even for those younger and "more spry" than I because of the possible consequences. No hobby (even photography, which has been my passion for those "more than 40 years") is worth the aggravation.
jrm, your avatar does not tell us where you live. ... (show quote)


I grew up in rural PA, and many of those narrow country roads were nothing but dirt roads until they were paved by the C.C.C. during the Great Depression. Individual property lines probably go right to the edge of the shoulder and perhaps the ditch since the roads originated just from convenient trails between farms and villages.

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 14:42:44   #
dennis2146 Loc: Eastern Idaho
 
insman1132 wrote:
Thanks, Dennis. I was also told that unless there is at least one strand of fencing erected the sign has no validity? Any idea if that is correct?


I have no idea. Each state has its own laws regarding trespassing. In some states if the land is not posted then the owner is giving a type of blanket permission for hunters, fishermen and whoever else to go on that land. If the land is posted it means no permission unless you ask for and receive permission. Some states state you need the land owners written permission to trespass. My land was always posted but if someone asked permission to hunt or cross the land then I gave it depending on what the people looked like, their demeanor and so on.

One year just near the close of the first hunting season a man, his wife and a small daughter drove up to the house and asked for permission to shoot a buck near the front of my driveway. I said that was fine but asked where by the driveway. As it turned out he was talking about property owned by my neighbor. I suggested if the deer was not on my property that evening then it would definitely be on my property the next morning or evening and told him exactly where to go to shoot it. He was kind enough to come back with some sausage for my wife and I. The following year I was off hunting elk and on opening morning about 5:00 AM this same man drove up our driveway waking up my wife to ask if he could hunt. She said No. Problem was it wasn't just this man but he had brought two other truckloads of hunters, probably six total that wanted to hunt. Had he come by himself and at a decent hour like a day or two before she probably would have given permission for HIM. My land wasn't enough to sustain 6 bucks to be taken. I also had family that hunted there.

Dennis

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 14:46:44   #
rehess Loc: South Bend, Indiana, USA
 
jrm21 wrote:
I'm in NY, but do spend a fair amount of time in PA.

Of course, there are roads with little to no shoulder for a car to park. That's the case for some roads in upstate NY too. BTW - that drainage ditch is typically part of the municipality's right of way.

I guess I should have made a common-sense disclaimer. If there is no shoulder where you can safely park your car, then maybe it's just not a good idea to park there for the sake of a photo?

If it's a dangerous place to stand without walking onto what is obviously private (or worse yet, posted) property, maybe you should find a safer location or ask permission from the property owner.

It is really worth blocking traffic, causing an accident, injuring yourself and/or someone else, or getting arrested just to get a picture of some random barn?


I only wanted to point out that where a shoulder IS available and there is a safe area to stand a few feet off the roadway, that area is most likely considered "public" property. For those that want to do this kind of thing, they should consult their own local laws for safety and legal considerations.

Where there is no shoulder or the area is dangerous to you or others, there are other reasons why you shouldn't be parking there and wandering off to take photos.
I'm in NY, but do spend a fair amount of time in P... (show quote)

Two comments on this thread, both based on the time we lived in Western Massachusetts:

1. Responding to aellman: When my wife first moved there, we used the copious number of "Dunkin Donuts" paking lots to turn around in. Within a few months, we learned that true natives just make a U-turn a the light, regardless of how it is marked.

2. Residents of New England go crazy over "colors" in the Fall. We never saw enough parking for the demand, so natives just seem to find a nearby place to stop and leave their cars there, regardless of how they are marked.

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 14:52:54   #
Steve V Loc: New Jersey
 
dennis2146 wrote:
I am talking about the government property.

Dennis


Dennis,

Ok. But I was hoping for some insight on the other part of my reply. As a hunter what do you think about the poaching. And should I tell the church?

Steve

Reply
 
 
Mar 22, 2020 15:08:38   #
dennis2146 Loc: Eastern Idaho
 
Steve V wrote:
Dennis,

Ok. But I was hoping for some insight on the other part of my reply. As a hunter what do you think about the poaching. And should I tell the church?

Steve


Forgive me. It has been a busy day at my house.

As a hunter I am definitely against poaching and rate it as a very serious crime. I would not only tell the property owners at the church but also notify the local fish and game warden to alert him too. As for the baiting it is legal in some states but not in others. I know in Texas it is legal but in Colorado it is definitely illegal. But the local warden can tell you whether it is legal or not. I can't tell you how strongly I feel though that you should let those people know.

Some poachers equate their illegal actions as to someone who has no meat in the house, is out of work and so on. While I can sympathize with people in that predicament and might do the same thing on my own private property the fact remains that those people are generally few and far between. Poachers generally do not kill a doe for meat but will pick out trophy animals to kill then take only the trophy parts, antlers, and let the rest of the animal go to waste. In most states killing an animal for the antlers and letting the meat go to waste is also a separate crime.

Dennis

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 15:15:04   #
Steve V Loc: New Jersey
 
dennis2146 wrote:
Forgive me. It has been a busy day at my house.

As a hunter I am definitely against poaching and rate it as a very serious crime. I would not only tell the property owners at the church but also notify the local fish and game warden to alert him too. As for the baiting it is legal in some states but not in others. I know in Texas it is legal but in Colorado it is definitely illegal. But the local warden can tell you whether it is legal or not. I can't tell you how strongly I feel though that you should let those people know.

Some poachers equate their illegal actions as to someone who has no meat in the house, is out of work and so on. While I can sympathize with people in that predicament and might do the same thing on my own private property the fact remains that those people are generally few and far between. Poachers generally do not kill a doe for meat but will pick out trophy animals to kill then take only the trophy parts, antlers, and let the rest of the animal go to waste. In most states killing an animal for the antlers and letting the meat go to waste is also a separate crime.

Dennis
Forgive me. It has been a busy day at my house. ... (show quote)


Thanks Dennis. Although I don’t always agree with all your opinions they are well spoken and thoughtful and as such I value them.

Hope all is well on your busy day.

Steve

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 15:24:51   #
dennis2146 Loc: Eastern Idaho
 
Steve V wrote:
Thanks Dennis. Although I don’t always agree with all your opinions they are well spoken and thoughtful and as such I value them.

Hope all is well on your busy day.

Steve


Thank you my friend. I don't agree with many people on here including some Conservatives but I consider just about everyone here my friend. If they needed something and I could help in any way I would not turn my back on them. I also learn much from people who do not share my opinions. If all we did was listen to the choir none of us would ever learn anything at all.

Things have settled down and I am doing great. Thank you.

Be safe and well,

Dennis

Reply
Mar 22, 2020 15:57:14   #
Steve V Loc: New Jersey
 
dennis2146 wrote:
Thank you my friend. I don't agree with many people on here including some Conservatives but I consider just about everyone here my friend. If they needed something and I could help in any way I would not turn my back on them. I also learn much from people who do not share my opinions. If all we did was listen to the choir none of us would ever learn anything at all.

Things have settled down and I am doing great. Thank you.

Be safe and well,

Dennis





Reply
 
 
Mar 23, 2020 05:38:53   #
hernyferd Loc: California and New York
 
dennis2146 wrote:
I see you are new. Welcome to the forum. It helps when replying to another poster if you click on Quote Reply before answering. That way we all know who you are addressing. Believe me it makes a big difference.

But let me ask, are you wanting to use the word, posited, or do you mean posted since the thread is about posting No Trespassing signs on property?

Dennis

Posited works in this instance. I did not know about the quote busness, so I shall apply thatas have here. Thanks for the welcome.

Reply
Mar 23, 2020 09:46:12   #
sr71 Loc: In Col. Juan Seguin Land
 
dennis2146 wrote:
Sorry to have to tell you but there is no such thing as an unofficial traffic law or any other law. In order to be valid laws must be written down so everyone is aware of them and there can be a penalty affixed if the law is broken. Perhaps what you are talking about is the use of common sense when turning in front of oncoming traffic.

Check with your local police officer and ask him what actual law he would cite you for disobeying IF you turned left in front of oncoming traffic so as to create an unsafe condition. I suspect he will have a specific law violation in mind.

Dennis
Sorry to have to tell you but there is no such thi... (show quote)


failure to heed the right a way to oncoming traffic

Reply
Mar 23, 2020 09:59:52   #
sr71 Loc: In Col. Juan Seguin Land
 
Steve V wrote:
Dennis,

Ok. But I was hoping for some insight on the other part of my reply. As a hunter what do you think about the poaching. And should I tell the church?

Steve


yes by all means, also inform the state fish and game of the incident. Poaching is illegal in all 50 states. I have no nice words for a poacher.

Reply
Mar 23, 2020 11:15:15   #
dennis2146 Loc: Eastern Idaho
 
sr71 wrote:
failure to heed the right a way to oncoming traffic


I believe that is what I said in my second paragraph.

Dennis

Reply
Page <<first <prev 15 of 16 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.