Editing someone else's image without at least asking....
Dec 8, 2019 14:25:06 #
Editing another’s image without being asked to or given permission is contrary to the rules of the forum as I read them (whether done by a section manager or not). Hoping that as soon as the manager reads your P/M, the issue will be resolved.
Dec 8, 2019 14:29:24 #
JoeJoe wrote:
Just a quick check on netiquette
Is it now acceptable to edit someone else's image without first asking permission??
This has happened twice in a number of weeks and appears to be directly for the poster's own inflated ego as both edits looked like they were edited by beginners???
Look forward to seeing if this has now changed on the Hog
Regards
Joe
Is it now acceptable to edit someone else's image without first asking permission??
This has happened twice in a number of weeks and appears to be directly for the poster's own inflated ego as both edits looked like they were edited by beginners???
Look forward to seeing if this has now changed on the Hog
Regards
Joe
AM not interested unless the OP asks for assistance.
Dec 8, 2019 16:27:21 #
JoeJoe wrote:
Unfortunately the Manager of the section has not responded to myself telling him not to edit my images.... I'll see if he has the decency to at least remove the offending image … I hate when HDR techniques are applied to people let alone baby's skin
Regards
Joe
Regards
Joe
Hi there. I m the culprit. I did not see your PM until late today and promptly removed the offending image. I do not monitor the section on a 24/7 basis. In that section, as manager, I do allow edits to illustrate corrections from time to time- they are not meant to represent finished work, just to point out various suggestions. I have removed the image and the accompanying critique. You original post remains for others to see or comment on. I was remiss in not noticing the notice in you signature.
I apologise for any upset I have caused. To avoid any further issues of this nature going forward, I will post some new or more specific rules for the section. I will explain how critiques are made and advise folks not to post sensitive, copyrighted material, or images that they don't wish to be reproduced in the section for reasons of critique.
All submissions to the section are welcomed and the section is not restricted to professional or advanced portraitists. I do however,, want to discourage "attaboy" comments so if someone thinks an image is "great, perfect, great capture" etc, the should state the reason for their opinion.
PS.:there no HDR applications. The image was edited on my tablet and the reproduction on a large screen WAS terrible!
Dec 8, 2019 16:41:01 #
E.L.. Shapiro wrote:
Hi there. I m the culprit. I did not see your PM ... (show quote)
Sorry Ed
You did not critique...
You added that it deserved advanced editing in your opinion... And who is going to do the advanced editing?? certainly not yourself
You then continued to poorly edit it....
As a so called professional I would expect at least a message of apology not a PM saying …
Quote
Done!!
And please ensure when you change the rules that you do not revisit my images to show your ability..... They are still copyrighted and you are not welcome to edit any of them...
Joe
Dec 8, 2019 16:45:53 #
One thing I have noticed is people who do edit without asking hardly ever post their own original work and when they do it is of really poor quality or out of focus... Makes you think why they do it??
Just a bit of food for thought
Just a bit of food for thought
Dec 8, 2019 16:52:10 #
Now who's out of line?
Btw JoeJoe you could have mentioned in your last post that you just today added this line to your posts, "Ask before you edit any of my images...… They are all copyrighted "
Btw JoeJoe you could have mentioned in your last post that you just today added this line to your posts, "Ask before you edit any of my images...… They are all copyrighted "
Dec 8, 2019 16:59:33 #
Rich1939 wrote:
Now who's out of line?
Btw JoeJoe you could have mentioned in your last post that you just today added this line to your posts, "Ask before you edit any of my images...… They are all copyrighted "
Btw JoeJoe you could have mentioned in your last post that you just today added this line to your posts, "Ask before you edit any of my images...… They are all copyrighted "
And how am I out of line...
Pointing out someone breaching general UHH rules on editing without permission...?? and not the first time
BTW I did on an earlier post do I need to add it to every post from now on????…
Joe
Dec 8, 2019 17:06:58 #
JoeJoe wrote:
And how am I out of line...
Pointing out someone breaching general UHH rules on editing without permission...?? and not the first time
BTW I did on an earlier post do I need to add it to every post from now on????…
Joe
Pointing out someone breaching general UHH rules on editing without permission...?? and not the first time
BTW I did on an earlier post do I need to add it to every post from now on????…
Joe
The man apologized and attempted to smooth the waters but I guess you didn't get your pound of flesh yet and proceeded to insult him.
Dec 8, 2019 17:07:11 #
JoeJoe wrote:
Sorry Ed br br You did not critique... br You ad... (show quote)
Read the post above yours! Then after apologizing maybe you should stop crying.
---
Dec 8, 2019 17:10:10 #
Bill_de wrote:
Read the post above yours! Then after apologizing maybe you should stop crying.
---
---
I also got a PM did you read that too...???
Dec 8, 2019 17:15:14 #
I'm sorry to drag this out but there WAS a critique offered in the post. I woud have not reproduced the image in any manner without an accompanying text. I made remarks about composition, space, possibility of vignetting, background etc. Of course, you have the right to disagree with any and all of that and object to the reproduction- no argument there!
I am also sorry that my apology was insufficient and not timely enough and you certainly needn't be concerned that I will reproduce any of you images. I addressed your demand as soon as I read the PM.
It is rare, on this forum, that anyone publicially apologizes for any and all kinds of inappropriate behavior. I suppose that many folks around here enjoy the infighting and like to add fuel to the fires and post unnecessary admonishments and reiteration of the rules even BEFORE an issue is settled between the parties concerned- a kinda gang mentality that sets in.
I am also sorry that my apology was insufficient and not timely enough and you certainly needn't be concerned that I will reproduce any of you images. I addressed your demand as soon as I read the PM.
It is rare, on this forum, that anyone publicially apologizes for any and all kinds of inappropriate behavior. I suppose that many folks around here enjoy the infighting and like to add fuel to the fires and post unnecessary admonishments and reiteration of the rules even BEFORE an issue is settled between the parties concerned- a kinda gang mentality that sets in.
Dec 8, 2019 17:17:30 #
JoeJoe wrote:
I also got a PM did you read that too...???
Yes. He advised privately that he removed the image in response to your complaint.
Then he apologized publicly. That shows character.
----
Dec 8, 2019 17:30:44 #
E.L.. Shapiro wrote:
I'm sorry to drag this out but there WAS a critiqu... (show quote)
I did disagree Ed …. so we will draw a line .. Have a good night..
Joe
Dec 8, 2019 19:08:06 #
JoeJoe wrote:
I did disagree Ed …. so we will draw a line .. Have a good night..
Joe
Joe
Good night to you as well, Joe. Peace! May we meet again under freiendler circumstances.
Ed
Dec 8, 2019 19:16:29 #
JoeJoe wrote:
Just a quick check on netiquette
Is it now acceptable to edit someone else's image without first asking permission??
This has happened twice in a number of weeks and appears to be directly for the posters own inflated ego as both edits looked like they were edited by beginners???
Look forward to see if this has now changed on the Hog
Regards
Joe
Is it now acceptable to edit someone else's image without first asking permission??
This has happened twice in a number of weeks and appears to be directly for the posters own inflated ego as both edits looked like they were edited by beginners???
Look forward to see if this has now changed on the Hog
Regards
Joe
I don't think it's acceptable without the permission of the person who took the photo.
I do not make money or prestige from my images (you have only to look at them to understand why). So read my signature.
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.