Bill Munny wrote:
Right now, as we speak, the govt purchasing group and a few other lettered organizations are testing out other pistols, as they do on a perpetual basis. One in major contention is the FN 5.7mm. It has a muzzle velocity of 2,800 fps (which makes it very loud), extremely light, very low recoil, mag holds 20 rounds and one in the chamber. The grip is very checkered for good control while wet and rarely hydraulics. Very nasty round, a .223 short. FN needs to get the price down ($1K each) to stay in contention. The years ago FBI tried using a 10mm (40 cal on steroids) but the recoil was too much to allow practice, it just hurt too much. They were testing them at our shooting range, along with 40 cal, 45 cal, 9mm and a 357 sig round. We set them up with scenarios so they could try each under stress and irregular situations. The 40 cal seemed to win as the most desired which was being used by the DoW sporting the double action S&W (and they quit using the S&W many years ago and went with Glocks).
Right now, as we speak, the govt purchasing group ... (
show quote)
I resisted jumping in on this topic. However I own two .40 caliber Glocks (G23 and G27) AND my carry weapon is a 10mm G29. The G27 stings my hands more than my 10mm. The 10mm G29 has a thicker heaver slide. It makes a big difference! The G29 can push you back but does not sting as much as the G27.
I'm not an expert on this subject. I'm just offering my opinion. I also fire FN 5.7mm ammo in my FN PS29. It's a fun gun. I do not consider it particular loud. Anything that exceeds the speed of sound makes a distinctive audible "crack." Hot 10mm are loud!
I takes some dedication to learn how to control the G29. I was lucky to get some one-on-one training from a professional bodyguard who guards politicians. He pointed out my mistakes to me. I would NOT recommend the G29 for a small thin person. I'm 6 foot tall and thin; it's my favorite weapon. Once you see what happens when a steel reactive target it hit by a hot 10 mm round, it's hard not to be impressed. They jump and spin! .40 does not do it as well.
Other weapons are also good on steel targets. .45s are impressive. I just prefer the 10mm.
My 2 cents.