This question is for folks more knowledgable than I. A fellow hogger displayed a beautifully lit sunflower a day or two ago. I thought it was outstanding and decided to use it for my desktop. I PM'd the Uhh'r to tell them how much I enjoyed the photo and that I was using it on my desktop. Well, this raised a legitimate question that I didn't have the answer to. Maybe someone can help out. They wanted to know "if it was common practice of individuals on this platform to use someone's work for their personal use (like my desktop) or for other purposes without first asking permission".
Are you requesting a show of hands from those who currently borrow them surreptitiously?
If a person is uneasy or upset to think that their online photos are being used by someone else (in whatever way), they probably shouldn't post them online.
I have too many of my own to care about using someone else's; however, if I were to download for inspiration or ideas, or to use on my personal computer desktop, I likely wouldn't bother to tell a stranger. If a UHH buddy, I would tell them.
I wouldn't know. Perhaps you can do a survey? I personally would never use others' photographs
If someone posts a photo on the internet it becomes public domain, that's been understood since the internet was created
I sometimes use other's pictures as backgrounds or components in a composite but never before asking and receiving permission.
I almost always ask, but am getting old now and sometimes I forget to message the photographer right away then I have to hunt up who took it and am not always successful. My purpose is to only study them or admire them and learn about how to be a better photographer. Then I delete most of them. I share them many times with a very old lady (90’s+) who is shut in and disabled with memory losses. She has a viewer on her table that the pictures will pop up on and they are the highlight of her day! They really give her happiness and a touch of excitement….hope that this sets well with ever.
terryMc
Loc: Arizona's White Mountains
tramsey wrote:
If someone posts a photo on the internet it becomes public domain, that's been understood since the internet was created
Except for legally, of course...
Shellback
Loc: North of Cheyenne Bottoms Wetlands - Kansas
UHH Terms of Use
For full Terms go to the bottom of the page and select the Terms of use link - also check out the Privacy policy link and the DMCA link...
USE OF INFORMATION FROM THIS WEBSITE
Unless you have entered into an express written contract with this website to the contrary, visitors, viewers, subscribers, members, affiliates, or customers have no right to use this information in a commercial or public setting; they have no right to broadcast it, copy it, save it, print it, sell it, or publish any portions of the content of this website. By viewing the contents of this website you agree this condition of viewing and you acknowledge that any unauthorized use is unlawful and may subject you to civil or criminal penalties. Again, Visitor has no rights whatsoever to use the content of, or portions thereof, including its databases, invisible pages, linked pages, underlying code, or other intellectual property the site may contain, for any reason for any use whatsoever. Nothing. Visitor agrees to liquidated damages in the amount of U.S.$100,000 in addition to costs and actual damages for breach of this provision. Visitor warrants that he or she understands that accepting this provision is a condition of viewing and that viewing constitutes acceptance.
OWNERSHIP OF WEBSITE OR RIGHT TO USE, SELL, PUBLISH CONTENTS OF THIS WEBSITE
The website and its contents are owned or licensed by the website. Material contained on the website must be presumed to be proprietary and copyrighted. Visitors have no rights whatsoever in the site content. Use of website content for any reason is unlawful unless it is done with express contract or permission of the website.
tramsey wrote:
If someone posts a photo on the internet it becomes public domain, that's been understood since the internet was created
That's because people "made" it that way!!
Posting on the internet does NOT negate or relinquish one's copyright to an image.
I simply makes it
available to people who don't give a crap about the creator's rights............
Their desire to have/use it is MUCH MORE IMPORTANT!
But, since enough people do it it is acceptable....
NOT!
Longshadow wrote:
That's because people "made" it that way!!
Posting on the internet does NOT negate or relinquish one's copyright to an image.
I simply makes it
available to people who don't give a crap about the creator's rights............
Their desire to have/use it is MUCH MORE IMPORTANT!
But, since enough people do it it is acceptable....
NOT!
That's because people "made" it that way... (
show quote)
What rights have they viloated using it as a screen saver? Copyright covers taking a photo and using it for some sort of profit without permission. That's is not a screen saver. If one is truely hyper, then put a subtle copyright through the center of the photo where it is most difficult to remove and no one will use it.
If someone wants to make a screen saver of one of my pictures, be my guest. I take that as a compliment not some egregious violation of the meaning of life.
pithydoug wrote:
What rights have they viloated using it as a screen saver? Copyright covers taking a photo and using it for some sort of profit without permission. That's is not a screen saver. If one is truely hyper, then put a subtle copyright through the center of the photo where it is most difficult to remove and no one will use it.
If someone wants to make a screen saver of one of my pictures, be my guest. I take that as a compliment not some egregious violation of the meaning of life.
That's not the point....
A copyright is a copyright! Regardless of what may be done with it. It is the photographer's property,
exclusively,
no ifs, ands, or buts.
Watermarks can be removed.
I have no problem with someone using a photo of mine as a screen saver either. I have been asked by someone they could copy the photo to make a painting. Very honorable of them. I said yes. A forum on Facebook asked if they could post one of my images on their FB page, I said yes. (And yes, it is a complement!)
It's called
respect for the photographer. Something seemingly less common nowadays.
I would be displeased if I arbitrarily found one of my shots on the net. Especially without accreditation or having requested permission to do so.
But I won't pursue it.
As a textbook author, I can assure you that if you use that photo for any reason other than your personal use, e.g. as a desktop image, especially if there is money involved, then you need to get permission. However, someone who posts photos on social media accepts the fact that those images will be used in ways, and by people, that they may not know about, and probably don’t care about.
Personally, I would never, ever use another's photo without permission simply because it is unethical.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.