chasgroh wrote:
...how "better?" Have you ran empirical tests between the two? Or is it testing done by others? I have On1 (which I use for infrared mostly) *and* Topaz (in which I do alot of work out of LR/P)...have yet to compare as I'm into my personal workflow, hard to break!
For the past several years I constantly have been evaluating and re-evaluating post processing software, both that designed for individual property adjustment and as packaged deals. I own or have owned a number of the major players, as well as several less well-known pretenders who have touted highly their product. For some time, I felt that there was no one product which was best at everything, but that for optimum results one had to use several of the programs then available, each for its individual strength. Some of the programs, I bought, but most offered trials, usually for 30 days. I did have one trial program which for some reason has continued to work without watermark or any problem. That is Topaz DeNoise 6 (64 bit), which was discontinued when they came out with their AI programs. In continued tests, I found DeNoise 6 to be better in almost all cases than the next several generations of their AI, and the best denoise program available – vs all the major players. I have owned and used ON1 for several years, and considered it to be close to, or as good as, the other majors – except in the denoise area. ON1 took a significant step ahead when they came out with their AI denoise version, but for a while it fell short in the correction of jpeg images. They since have remedied that, and its performance is the best of anything I have tried (but which does not include the latest Topaz offering). In that the latest update of ON1 2022.5 is the best post processing software – in all respects – available, and since I couldn’t afford the costly Topaz software anyway, I now will not even waste the time to look at it, As a side note, I have almost no noise problems to correct, which makes my decision even easier. In evaluating the performance of denoise programs, I would scour the Internet for examples of noisy images, and work primarily with those. In no case did I use AI software as the be-all, end-all correction, but as a starting point, just as I would use presets – if I were to use them – which I very seldom do. I now have determined, to my satisfaction, that ON1 Photo RAW 2022.5, latest update, is the very best post processing software available in all areas, the easiest to learn and use, the best by far in data management, the most logical in workflow, and the equivalent, at least, of any with respect to support (they solicit owner suggestions and answer questions on a very timely basis) and good training videos. It provides all this in one program, without the requirement of jumping back and forth between programs. As a result of all the foregoing, I now use ON1 only, especially on RAW, but also on jpg, and will not be wasting my time with anything else!
Sorry for the length of this post, but as I went along, I decided that as long as I was answering the question, I should answer it completely.
Loren – in Beautiful Baguio City