Abo wrote:
The Lucas fuel pump/ignition is/was not the problem...
the problem is American mechanics.
Anything they did not see in their apprenticeship/not made in the good ol' USA
is totally "foreign"... and that's the problem.
At 17 years old I bought my first car; a BMC Mini which had that Lucas
fuel pump and ignition system... as easy as pie to set up/service.
And once I'd set and serviced those systems, they were 100% reliable... 100%!!!
And zero electrical problems of any kind! Zero!
Having said that, the engine in the Mini is East/West and the distributor
faces forward right behind and close to the centre of the grill...
driving through water could get condensation on the inside of the dizzy
cap, causing misfires... which was very easily remedied by unclipping
the cap, giving it a squirt with WD40... LPS etc then a wipe out
with a rag... refit the dizzy cap... 2 minutes work and all was good.
And water in the dizzy cap will present the same problem with
Delco, Bosch, AC, FoMoCo, Mopar, Bendix... whatever... of that "ignition points" era.
The Lucas fuel pump/ignition is/was b not /b the... (
show quote)
With all due respect to another accomplished wrench turner, I have to disagree. It reminds me of a British car salesman telling me “that you just need to tighten your sump bolts mate” when I was complaining about the myriad fluid leaks.
I grew up owning and working on British cars (had to - no money wile in school or the military). My first car was an Anglia, then a Cortina, a Sunbeam Alpine series II, followed by 2 bug eye Sprites, an 850 Mini, a TR Spitfire, TR4, MGA (with a B engine), a 1275 Mini and a Jaguar MKII. I’ve rebuilt easily a dozen British engines (we used to race Morgans in SCCA), Girling and Lockheed Brakes, Armstrong shocks, Autopulse electric pumps, Smith gauges, SUs (I still have my Unisyn), and Lacock de Normaville overdrives. And I can’t tell you the times I’ve been left on the road with failed Lucas generators, bad distributor caps, starters that wouldn’t start and melting wiring harnesses (the TR4 only had 2 fuses - one for each headlight - everything else was unfused). Lucas has earned their reputation fair and square, and it isn’t a good one, and I DO know how to work on British cars. I have owned a couple of Saabs and a Volvo, but the only American cars I’ve owned have been company supplied cars. I do ALL my own work when required including fuel injection.
The day I sold my TR4 to the service manager of the BMC dealership (he didn’t even make it home before the car died) and the Jag (which developed an electrical problem between the buyer’s test drive and the delivery) we’re the best days of my automotive life. I bought my first new car - a BMW 2002 off the showroom floor (rather than the TR6 I’d been considering) and never looked back. I went on to work with some pros who raced a 2002 in IMSA (I was the Weber tuner and ran the engine dyno and worked the flow bench). Went Japanese for awhile with a 280Z, then a pair of 911s before my first Lexus in 93 and my first Mercedes in 97. Now I never buy anything except Japanese and German.
I’ve only had 2 recent experiences with British cars. I helped a friend sell a Jag XJ-8 (he’d been either left on the road or spent a fortune at the shop too many times). It was a pristine car, and I almost bought it myself for a spare car until I saw the service records and the amount spent (almost 14K$ in 70K miles was just astronomical). One of my system engineers at Oracle was driving a new Aston Martin when I went to work there. Turned out his wife had won a 2 year lease in a sales contest. He said it had been picked up on a carrier and returned to the shop 8 times in the first year due to electrical problems. Not sure Aston still uses Lucas or not.
Don’t get me wrong - I love many British cars - I think the E-type is one of the most beautiful automobiles ever built, and there are 50+ years of Road and Tracks in my attic, but I’ve paid my dues, and when my 15 year old Merc and my 13 year old Lexus need replacing (neither of which leak anything), it will likely be another Lexus. I think Toyota is making some of the most reliable automobiles in the world. I love Mercedes, but with their CANbus electronics, they’re getting hard and expensive to work on when they do break, and at 75, reliability and quality has become key to me.
Cheers,
Chris