boberic
Loc: Quiet Corner, Connecticut. Ex long Islander
The shorter focal length L Canon lenses are black, while all of the longer lenses are white. Just curious as to why.
Because the long lenses are so large that if they were black the heat from the sun would cause them to expand and change dimensions and throw off the focus etc. At least that's the theory. The shorter lenses don't heat up as much because there isn't as much surface to heat up.
The white versions add another $ to the cost ($$$ becomes $,$$$). Is that what you want for every lens?
CHG_CANON wrote:
The white versions add another $ to the cost ($$$ becomes $,$$$). Is that what you want for every lens?
It cost more to paint them white?
boberic wrote:
The shorter focal length L Canon lenses are black, while all of the longer lenses are white. Just curious as to why.
Because it looks cool and nobody else did it until recently.
rgrenaderphoto wrote:
Because it looks cool and nobody else did it until recently.
Nikon had some white/grey lens in the past.
Don
jeep_daddy wrote:
Because the long lenses are so large that if they were black the heat from the sun would cause them to expand and change dimensions and throw off the focus etc. At least that's the theory. The shorter lenses don't heat up as much because there isn't as much surface to heat up.
In the real world though I doubt it makes much, if any, difference.
I like the thermal expansion inference.... ever notice that all astronauts wear white "space suits"
While a single photon does pack much of a wallop, in aggregate incoming from direct sunlight can indeed push the envelope to a point where the thermal expansion coefficient may likely take a toll on lens components... But then again, possibly Nikkors are made of sterner stuff... so they likely can handle it... I did notice that Nikon now uses cooling fans on it's high end speedlights... the thermal cutout on the SB900 was not a crowd pleaser... and Nikon limits burst modes on the D500 in order to keep the shutter from overheating... even sensor noise increases with ambient temperature... got to keep it cool...
According to some web found material, In the past, Canon used white bodies for temperature stability which would help the larger glass elements become more consistent in its performance. Later on, even with changes in technology, the general idea continued as the white lenses become a Canon brand identity.
They're not really white, they are very light grey.
I was told by a fellow Pro' (He's a Canon man, I'm a Nikon man)While he was covering the Tennis action in Outdoors Australia, black tele' lens internal elements were "steaming up inside". But 'White' coated barrels were remaining cool, and clear. That was back in the 1970's / 80's.
mwsilvers wrote:
In the real world though I doubt it makes much, if any, difference.
If it did, all manufacturers would be making white, reflective or light-toned lenses. Black lenses would be a thing of the past.
sb
Loc: Florida's East Coast
rmorrison1116 wrote:
They're not really white, they are very light grey.
Darn! and I just spray-painted all my lenses white!
sb wrote:
Darn! and I just spray-painted all my lenses white!
Be careful! Getting the over-spray off the lens elements takes a steady hand with a razor blade!
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.