Both are great but I'm with #1.
I like the composition better of number 2, but the tonal range is too dark.
Both are very well done, but the download on #2 sold me. So, that's my choice.
I like it without the fence, Maybe the fence is just too much.
I like #1 but the there's something about the fence that bothers me. My vote is #2. Maybe a slight lightening of the exposure and/or not as much vignetting. I really like the composition of that one.
Looks like the ones have it.
#2 has the best composition, but the exposure and colors in #1 are better.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.