Quote:
I know you and Linda have been thinking about a thread along these lines Min, and I go way the day you post it! Never mind, a bit late in the debate I would like to add my two-penn'th.
There have been some masterful examples posted in the thread, Dixiegirls sublime images are a great example done with skill, Piet's ships, and others have been really enhanced with textures carefully used.
Billy taught me, shortly after I got my hands on Topaz, to take care not to overdo the effect - although this does, I think, depend very much on the image and personal taste - apply with caution is a good tip.
Sometimes I like to slap a good dollop on though! The image below is suffering from what many of my snapped portraits suffer, and thats a bright background. So, why not add a texture that contributes as part of the shot - I'm seeing this texture as a sailcloth behind the subject, perfectly in keeping with his pirate pose. Of course it's masked from the subject face. That way I don't have to end-up with a dulled-down drab beach behind him. Does it work? Well, for me yes, but, as I've said, it's personal taste.
br br I know you and Linda have been thinking ab... (
show quote)
The texture works well here to bring the background into better balance with the image itself. I often mask out some degree of the texture effect on the main subject, though seldom all of it, just so it holds together better. Sometimes there are splats and bumps in the texture that don't need to be on faces. But the texture, here, adds to rather than detracts from the image, which is what we want it to do, whether we are going for a subtle effect like Dixie Girls or more grungy effects like I tend to do.
And we can keep the thread going as long as anyone wants to post to it! I was hoping some folks that were new to textures would try it out and post some experiments. As you mentioned, it helps to have some one to share these things with. Also helps keep us from going overboard!
Topaz is just a tool like any other. Any of them can be taken too far. It is possible to totally wreck a photo without ever leaving Lightroom. Understanding the tools and harnessing them to do what you want is always gonna be necessary.