Linda From Maine wrote:
Though I haven't quite achieved "mystery, less literal" (per the article) or your mention of causing the viewer to wonder what is going on, I did - after many failings - accomplish another that I like as much in negative as positive :)
Textures are PS Elements "note paper" and Topaz Simplify oil painting. The ground was snow-covered. Any advice gladly received. Thank you, Jim!
In my opinion #1 is the image that is stronger. It does have those things we have been discussing. With this one you have entered the world of fine art museum quality which many curators would highly consider. Especially if you had several more on this manner and of different subject matter.
It a marvelous piece. You won't find many hoggers who agree but that's another matter. Excellent use of the medium.