macc wrote:
Have used this recipe for a long time, like it, but am still trying to get consistent shelling results. Have tried the "rinse with cold water refill and add ice cubes " etc. but none of the methods yield a "consistent" method of peeling, without tearing off the last layer on egg white, in rough patches. Sometimes it works great, and others we have to make egg salad rather than Deviled eggs.. Anyone have any other suggestions? Thanks!
I have been through the difficulties of removing the shell from hard boiled eggs, and I have heard the numerous reasons why that occurs (age of eggs, etc) but those difficulties, I have no longer. Two reasons may apply here, but I am not sure which is the most effective, as my wife now does the hard-boiling part, and I remove the shells part. Here is how she hard boils the eggs:
Place refrigerated eggs in cold water; set stove to medium-high heat, let it reach a boil, and let boil for 10 minutes or so (she uses a timer, but sometimes it goes a little longer); cover; remove from heat; let stand for 20 minutes; rinse twice in cold water.
Now for my side of things: I think it has to lot to do with how one goes about removing the shell. I read this on-line, a few months back, from a fire-fighter-fellow (cook) who makes hard-boiled eggs for his fire-engine house:
He takes the hard-boiled eggs just after they are done and shakes them in an empty (no water) container (I suppose the one he used to cook them in) until they are all cracked all over their surfaces. He says he never has a problem with removing the shells.
Since I do not eat a pail of hard-boiled eggs at one time, I just take one from the frig and place it under small stream of running warm water, and then I rap the egg back and forth against the side of the sink, just hard enough to break the shell at each rap, while held loosely in my hand, so that it turns randomly at each rap, and I continue until it is thoroughly broken all over its surface.
Finally, while under running warm water I do NOT pick/pull at the broken shell pieces, but instead push one broken section against another by placing my thumbnail under the first a broken section and slide it toward another. Once the next one or two sections begin to loosen and move, the whole surface shell with membrane attached slides off of the egg.
I have not had a problem since we have used these methods, but honestly, I don't know if it is the way my wife cooks the eggs, the way I remove the shell, or a combination of both.
Good luck!