rpavich wrote:
I wouldn't try to convince him I would ask him to convince me.
The fact is saturated fat and heart disease are not linked. Their connection was based on bad science. Here is a short, humorous video that summarizes the whole thing. If you want the studies behind it all then look up Gary Taubes books
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8WA5wcaHp4Gary Taubes has been exposed as a charlatan. The diet he recommends is basically an Atkins diet.
"The Diet Fad of the 21st Century"
Allowing a good 20 years for dieters to forget Dr. Atkins past failure, the book was reissued as Dr. Atkins
New Diet Revolution (though there was not much new about it) in 1992.[39] Along with other retro 70s
fashions, and this time backed by an aggressive marketing campaign, it became the best-selling fad-diet
book in history[40] achieving "fashion-cult status amongst society figures."[520]
What may have truly made it "The Diet Fad of the 21st Century" (as an editor of the Journal of the
American Dietetics Association coined it)[41] came a decade later with the publication of the infamous
pro-Atkins New York Times Magazine article "What If Its All Been a Big Fat Lie."[42] Atkins quickly
wrote an editorial for his Web site claiming the article "validated" his work. Gushingly favorable
follow-up stories appeared on NBCs Dateline, CBS 48 Hours, and ABCS 20/20. The Atkins
corporation claimed literally billions of media hits.[43] By the time the articles many flaws were exposed
weeks later, the book had already catapulted to #1 on a New York Times bestseller list and Atkins net
worth zoomed to $100 million.[44]
The piece was written by freelance writer and Atkins advocate[45] Gary Taubes (who reportedly scored a
book deal from it--and a $700,000 advance).[46] The Washington Post investigated his pro-Atkins article
and found that Taubes simply ignored all the research that didnt agree with his conclusions.
www.AtkinsExposed.org - 4 - 8 Nov 2004 20:39
Atkins Exposed Dr. Michael Greger
Taubes evidently interviewed a number of prominent obesity researchers and then twisted their words.
"What frightens me," said one, "is that he picks and chooses his facts.... If the facts dont fit in with his
yarn, he ignores them."[47]
The article seemed to claim that experts recommended the diet. "I was greatly offended at how Gary
Taubes tricked us all into coming across as supporters of the Atkins Diet," said John Farquhar, a Professor
Emeritus of Medicine at Stanford. When the Director of the Center for Human Nutrition at the
Washington University School of Medicine was asked to comment of one of Taubes claims, he replied,
"Its preposterous."[48]
"He took this weird little idea and blew it up," said Farquhar, "What a disaster."[49]
"The article was written in bad faith," said another quoted expert. "It was irresponsible."[50] "I think hes
a dangerous man. Im sorry I ever talked to him." Referring to the book deal, "Taubes sold out."[51]
What the researchers stressed was how dangerous saturated fat and meat consumption could be, but
Taubes seemed to have conveniently left it all out. "The article was incredibly misleading," said the
pioneering Stanford University endocrinologist Gerald Reaven who actually coined the term Syndrome X.
"I tried to be helpful and a good citizen," Reaven said, agreeing to do the interview, "and I ended up being
embarrassed as hell. He sort of set me up... I was horrified."[52]