Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Reading left-to-right affects image composition? Proof?
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
Sep 24, 2014 18:54:28   #
moonhawk Loc: Land of Enchantment
 
PhotosBySteve wrote:
For me, I find it beneficial at times to turn my art upside down for a different perspective which sometimes helps to direct my attention to areas I could not see in the original perspective.



I've never used a view camera, but those who do say that the upside down view one sees is an aid to composing. Don't know if it's also reversed left to right, but I've always tried to view my subject matter as shapes, and compose--whether in camera or in PP, accordingly.

Reply
Sep 24, 2014 23:11:02   #
prayingmantis
 
MAANDERSON, You have brought up an issue of right versus left brain dominance and the capacities of each hemisphere of the brain of which there is quite a bit known. That whole field of knowledge has become quite important over the last 4 decades in determining how best to teach students to use their entire brain. The whole science which elucidated the functional differences between the left and right hemispheres was fortuitous when it was discovered that there is a rare congenital defect in which a large bundle of nerve fibers known as the corpus callosum and which connects the two hemispheres is absent in those individuals. As a result the two hemispheres have been tested individually with regard to a whole battery of psychological capacities. This was done by showing the subjects separate screens with a barrier in the middle such that information being fed to the left hemisphere was isolated from the right hemisphere by the placement of a barrier. Some of what has been determined is relevant to this discussion. Right handed individuals who make up the majority of mankind (Obama is the only exception, LOL) are left brain dominant and left handed individuals are usually right brain dominant. The left brain dominant individuals who are the majority are more capable of seeing the greater picture and its component parts and also better with verbal processing and verbal skills. The left brain is said to think linearly, coming to a final conclusion in solving a problem in a step wise fashion. On the other hand the right brain sees the parts of the whole and is more adept at the synthesis of the whole from its parts. It is said to function in parallel while the left brain in series.
The right brain has hardly any function with regard to verbal processing however it is heavily involved in visual and spatial information and can create abstractions which the left brain is incapable of carrying out. It is said to be the hemisphere which dominates the artistic side of the individual. No one individual is entirely right brain or left brain functionally however they are rarely equally capable on both sides. There are educators now who have been for quite some time trying to create curriculums that address and strengthen the skills of each side of the brain. It is believed by some that current curriculums give advantages to one side or the other.
To PhotosBySteve, I have actually displayed a couple of my photos in a gallery upside down from the way it was taken. I found it more effective that way although I rarely flip them in Photoshop and look at them. One of the images I did it with was a reflection in a reflecting pool in the castle known as the Alhambra in Granada, Spain. I have also flipped a reflected image in Yosemite and displayed it that way. The reaction of patrons was interesting.

Reply
Sep 24, 2014 23:15:24   #
moonhawk Loc: Land of Enchantment
 
Is it the right brain or the left brain that tells us when to use paragraphs?

Reply
 
 
Sep 25, 2014 00:10:01   #
prayingmantis
 
That would probably be the left brain. I just let the info flow without any editing.

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 00:35:23   #
moonhawk Loc: Land of Enchantment
 
prayingmantis wrote:
That would probably be the left brain. I just let the info flow without any editing.


Fair enough--It's just that it makes both sides of my brain hurt...

:lol: :lol:

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 08:21:14   #
JCam Loc: MD Eastern Shore
 
prayingmantis wrote:
That would probably be the left brain. I just let the info flow without any editing.


Why not make it really flow and make it all one sentence? :thumbdown:

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 15:48:14   #
djenrette Loc: Philadelphia
 
The left side of the brain controls the right side of the body. We are mostly right handed. By writing, drawing, or painting with the right hand we can more easily see what we are doing. Therefor left to right.

Reply
 
 
Sep 25, 2014 15:48:53   #
djenrette Loc: Philadelphia
 
The left side of the brain controls the right side of the body. We are mostly right handed. By writing, drawing, or painting with the right hand we can more easily see what we are doing. Therefor left to right.

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 18:14:34   #
Shutter Bugger
 
manderson wrote:
Dave, first of all, don't you get a headache from thinking so hard. Do you think the left to right preference maybe has to do with right hand dominance. I don't know if right hand dominance is worldwide or not though. This may be a western thing only.


Go to a Chinese restaurant and check out if the waiters and cooks are predominately right
handed.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjWkO9A-Ckk

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hvAfQqWAL4 :thumbup:


The left half of your brain controls the right half of your body,
and the right half of your brain controls the left half of your body.

So, only left handed people are in their right minds. ;-)

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 18:18:40   #
Shutter Bugger
 
dpullum wrote:
Was prayingmantis concise; "giving a lot of information clearly and in a few words; brief but comprehensive." I would say so and agree Jer comment "great and thoughtful discussion."

The discussion could have covered several pages or a chapter in a book.

It is too rare that we have a learnered discussion of our serious hobbie or profession. The angst that Woody Alan and I feel when creating is significant. I work hard on a photo before submitting to the howelling wolves that are the judges at the Camera Club... looking for a vunerable spot to sink in teeth.

This iron-cladding of my photos has taught me a lot and forced me to conform. Once I conformed and won 3rd place in the years competition... I was free to be me. Now I create as tho art.. to please me. Strange, I still mostly get award winning rating monthly even tho I do not follow the "norm."

I spent two hours searching for a definitive study saying that in USA drive on the right culture we look left to upper right. Eye string analysis an academic article never got around to saying any thing clear... unless an algorithm is clear!! But string analysis.. a plot of how the eye tracks on a photo would do the trick.

One of the methods I use in examining a photo for weight, balance and color balance is to take off my glasses or to use a filter to make the photo look like bumpy obscure glass. Key is the detail disappears and only the lines shapes and colors are there for us to see. If the photo passes that "squint test" then it is probably a good photo. Adding some dissonance to a photo is a winning trick... field of yellow flowers with one red one isolated and alone.

Notice the hawk on page 2. Looking at it we see the shadow line going from lower left to upper right.

Surly there is a definitive study out there... where is the question.

PS: before you cross the street be sure to look left then start walking to the island and look right before you proceeded to the other side of the street!! Oh gosh like with a photo!
Was prayingmantis concise; "giving a lot of ... (show quote)

:-)

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 20:21:52   #
LoneRangeFinder Loc: Left field
 
MtnMan wrote:
BTW several of the articles I looked out found a preference for left to right lighting...from both cultures but more so from left to right reading cultures. I Googled images from DaVinci and Rembrandt (the master of Light) and it does seem to me that they use left to right lighting in most of their side lit images.

That one is easy to map to photo composition.



Hmmm. I don't know if this is apropos to the discussion but DaVinci wrote his studies in "mirror" script which is to say he wrote from right to left and with the letters reversed as well.

My daughter does this. I've observed her write and there is no concerted effort so I doubt that it is an affectation.

Reply
 
 
Sep 25, 2014 20:51:12   #
prayingmantis
 
When I first learned to write I had the pencil automatically placed in my right hand. I started to write my name with the letters flipped from left to right. For example the name SCOTT was not spelled TTOCS but rather with the letters in the right order but with the S and the C flipped left to right. The letters O and T were written correctly as they are symmetrical. My parents took me to a learning disorder specialist (this would be about 1955) and he told my parent I was probably left handed. I was then instructed to use my left hand and the disorder was solved. Given how long ago that consult occurred it amazes me that the therapist got it correct. It might be something to look into for your daughter.

Reply
Sep 25, 2014 20:53:53   #
LoneRangeFinder Loc: Left field
 
prayingmantis wrote:
When I first learned to write I had the pencil automatically placed in my right hand. I started to write my name with the letters flipped from left to right. For example the name SCOTT was not spelled TTOCS but rather with the letters in the right order but with the S and the C flipped left to right. The letters O and T were written correctly as they are symmetrical. My parents took me to a learning disorder specialist (this would be about 1955) and he told my parent I was probably left handed. I was then instructed to use my left hand and the disorder was solved. Given how long ago that consult occurred it amazes me that the therapist got it correct. It might be something to look into for your daughter.
When I first learned to write I had the pencil aut... (show quote)


She has finished college...so I don't know....

But thanks.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.