Kiron Kid wrote:
Impact, feeling and passion, always trump technical skill and expertise.
Very often images lacking good composition, density, color, sharpness, over processed or other digital processes will not make the first cut.
I attended this last July the 70th Anniversary edition of New England Camera Club Council's annual conference held at Amherst, UMASS. The competition used PSA rules which are quite stingent to "Nature" and "Open" categories:
According to PSA rules on Nature category: Images entered in the digital projected image nature competition must conform to PSAs nature definition. Eligible subjects include trees, wildflowers, weeds, grasses, fungi, ferns, mosses, animals or birds (except domesticated), reptiles, insects, fossils, weather, land/seascapes (without boats or other human evidence), geological formations, etc. Ineligible subjects include cultivated plants or flowers, domestic animals (dogs, cows, etc), scenes that show human artifacts (fences, buildings, telephone wires, etc.), mounted specimens, museum habitats or groups, or subjects no longer alive.
"Nature photography is restricted to the use of the photographic process to depict observations from all branches of natural history, except anthropology and archeology, in such a fashion that a well informed person will be able to identify the subject material and to certify as to its honest presentation. The story telling value of a photograph must be weighed more than the pictorial quality. Human elements shall not be present, except on the rare occasion where those human elements enhance the nature story. The presence of scientific bands on wild animals is acceptable. Photographs of artificially produced hybrid plants or animals, mounted specimens, or obviously set arrangements, are ineligible, as is any form of manipulation, manual or digital, that alters the truth of the photographic statement. Authentic Wildlife is defined as one or more organisms living free and unrestrained in a natural or adopted habitat. Therefore, photographs of zoo animals or photographs of game farm animals regardless of the game farms use of wildlife terminology are not considered wildlife images. Makers may perform any enhancements and modifications that improve the presentation of the image that could have been done at the time the image was taken but that does not change the truth of the original nature story. Cropping and horizontal flipping (equivalent to reversing a slide) are acceptable modifications. Addition of elements, removal of elements other than by cropping, combining elements from separate images, rearranging elements or cloning elements ARE NOT ACCEPTABLE.
Open Category: "Digital Realism" includes enhancements and modifications allowed to improve a presentation but without changing the taken truth of the original exposure. "Digital Realism" allow adjustments to exposure, contrast, sharpness, acceptable cropping, altering between horizontal and vertical, enhancement of overall color (like you do when you choose a film) but not change the color of sky, for example. Removal of elements, such as telephone wires, is permissible. "Digital Art" includes digital images that exceed the definition of "Digital Realism."
I declined to enter the competition.
Best wishes and go out and get those great images!
Ed