mbarrett635 wrote:
I have both lenses. I use the 28-300 when I travel for its 'all in one' ability, but as others have said, it is both large and heavy, and it's not the sharpest lens in my bag by far. But it is far from what I'd call bad. Its kind of like a saying about tires -- "long lasting, great handling, cheap: you can only have two at any one time." The same is true of lenses. If this were as sharp as my recently acquired 70-200mm f/2.8E FL ED VR (an amazing lens btw, especially when paired with my D5), then the 28-300 would no doubt be even heavier and more expensive.
Ultimately it comes down to what you want. If you want the sharpest lens possible, then this isn't the one for you (get the 70-200 I mentioned); but you'll lose reach on both ends, plus it's bigger (although it doesn't seem heavier). If you want convenience in an all around package, this is a good choice, but maybe the Tamron someone mentioned might be a better one.
If you are just looking to get into full frame photography, then maybe there are other completely different lenses you should consider, depending upon what you are shooting. I have a Nikon 24-70mm f/2.8G ED that is incredibly sharp, and is my go to lens for portrait or event photography. Its also about $600 cheaper then the newer VR version, and I've never felt that I was missing anything by not having image stabilization on this lens. The Nikon 24-120mm f/4G ED VR is about $700 cheaper than the 24-70 (it's not as fast), but would seem to be a good lens for a general purpose walk-around full frame lens. I don't own one, but it appears to be generally well reviewed. If your interests tend toward landscape photography, you might look for something even wider.
I realize I've digressed somewhat from your initial question about the 28-300, but as with most things, different tools are better (or worse) for different jobs. It all comes down to what you want to do, and of course, what do you want to pay.
I have both lenses. I use the 28-300 when I trave... (
show quote)
Very helpful to hear of your experiences with the different lenses. I appreciate the help.