WOw..I haven't logged on in a while, so I am so sorry it took so long to respond to you my friend. First, let me say thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed response. I have always valued what you have told me. You are correct, this is my first real jump into beauty studio photography where I really thought out the lighting , hair, makeup and outfit choice. I have to say that although I agree with some of what you have said, I do not agree with all of it. I am quite happy with the outcome of this first venture as I was able to achieve certain goals that I had in mind for myself. I was looking for a darker, moodier look for my models. I am very happy with the flower photo and the bare shoulder I tend to disagree with you about. But that is a matter of absolute opinion. I do know that there is much room to grow and learn from this step as it is my real first one. I learn from every single cc from everyone. I evaluate what I personally agree with and disagree with and grow from there, so I really thank you for your feedback. :)
jonsommer wrote:
Hi Alissa Beth, your photos that you share on this forum are usually so sensitive, so personal, tender and reflective and even often so vulnerable that they can be very emotionally revealing of both the model and the photographer. I hate to say this, but these, I feel, miss the mark. I’ll just comment on the first one, so let’s start with the crop, look at your models hands, the fingers look swollen and thick, which I’m pretty sure that in real life they’re not, but they distract and should be eliminated by cropping them out. Next, your pose isn’t flattering, like our own and magnificently talented as well as delightfully frank Captain C has often said, shooting over a woman’s bare shoulder will always give the shoulder more dominance in the photo than it should have (he might not have said it exactly like that, but something close to it) there is actually more skin showing in the models shoulder and chest than in her lovely face, so raise the camera, drop the shoulder and bring her wrap up to cover more of her skin, we the viewers, don’t want to be distracted by the skin on her shoulders which is here keeping us from looking at her face. It’s already been mentioned that a hair light would help, but don’t stop there. Add a fill light to lighten the shadows in her face which will help in making her look much more feminine, and a background light to give some much needed separation from your new (and quite beautiful) background. Finally, I have to comment on your model’s makeup, it’s very subtle, but the color difference between her warm shoulder and her face, well, to me, her face color has taken on a slightly blue-ish and chalky look, or it’s a little too shiny or something, that it just doesn’t flatter your model they way it should or could and I must admit that I don’t know if it’s the light or the makeup (or even my own eyes) that’s causing it. One more comment if I may, about her hair. In the poses without a flower on her camera left side, the hair on her camera right right side is beautiful, full and nicely flowing, but the left doesn’t match that beautiful full flow and just comes across as flat. Remember, every journey starts with the first few steps, don’t get discouraged because you’re not “there” yet, you’ve proven that you have tons and tons of talent, and I know that you can do this, too!
Hi Alissa Beth, your photos that you share on this... (
show quote)