Gene51 wrote:
Using DX crop gives you the same result as cropping in post. No advantage as far as image quality is concerned. You are taking a camera that provides a 7,360 x 4,912 px image and turning it into one that only gives you 4,800 x 2,704 px, or 15.3 mp. If you routinely already crop your images, your image quality will not change - you'll just have fewer cropping options.
As far as you lens is concerned, you still have a 70-200, only using that smaller part of the center of the image as recorded by the sensor. The only advantage is you can shoot at 5 fps instead of 4 with the standard battery, or if you have a MB-D12 and either the alkaline battery tray or the EN-EL18 battery and BL-5 cover you can go to 5 fps.
A better option if you have the battery grip is to go to 1.2 format. You will still get a bump in FPS - to about 5 - and a bigger image - 6,144 x 4,080 px or 25mp.
It's hard to compose in the cropped view, especially if you have a lens with a small maximum aperture. All you get are guide lines, so you actually see the entire D800 frame, with the crop lines superimposed.
The 70-200 VRII does a very decent job with the 1.4 and the 1.7 TC, but you will get even better performance if you get the 200-500, and better yet if you get the 150-600 Tamron G2 or the Sigma Sport.
There is no magic shortcut to great image quality - you have a camera that can capture great resolution, now you just need to decide which of the long lenses you are going to get. Forget about a 70-300 - if you are happy with the 70-200, but not thrilled when you add a 1.4 TC, you won't be happy at all with the 70-300.
This is an image taken with a Sigma Sport at 600mm, using a D800, and cropped down to 3.9 mp (1747x2236). I made a print at 72 ppi for a finished image size of 24x31 (roughly) and it looked very crisp. Of course you will see flaws and softness if you hold it 10 inches from your face and use a loupe, but hanging on a wall, in a frame, with a nice 2" border around it, and viewed at a normal viewing distance of 4 ft or so, (1.5x the diagonal dimension), it's just fine and no one will complain that it isn't sharp.
Using DX crop gives you the same result as croppin... (
show quote)
That is a beautiful photo Gene 51.
Thanks for providing all of your information. It's very interesting and helpful.