dkeysser wrote:
Guys, I received some very helpful responses (and a couple of snarky ones that I ignored). Let me clarify - I do not want to shoot B&W photos of colorful items, like red roses. If I want to shoot a photo of a red rose, it will be in color. The reason I am attracted to monochrome is for shots of things that have little color: old derelict buildings in the evening, nightime downtown shots, desert scenes, night clubs and concerts. I grew up shooting grainy gritty B&W shots on a Leica (Tri-X, D76 1:1) of nighttime street scenes, and that is what I want to recreate. Given that, does any have different suggestions and ideas than posted earlier? Thanks again.
Guys, I received some very helpful responses (and ... (
show quote)
You have a number of options to recreate and look of B&W shots with Tri-X and D76. The simplest method to do this is to shoot in color than convert to monochrome in Post. There are several good options for this type of post processing. I've used Lightroom/Photoshop both to good effect in converting a color raw image to monochrome. If what I'm after is a older grittier look then I frequently shoot in color and use Photoshop to convert the image. Creating an orthochromatic film look is easier from a conversion, generating the look of panchromatic film is similarly easier.
Using a monochromatic camera such as the Leica Monochrome is a whole different experience. In some ways its more film like than using a regular digital camera. Just like with B&W film altering the chromatic response requires the use of a filter at exposure time. The biggest difference between a monochrome digital camera and film is the fact that its actually more panchromatic than film - even without a filter blue skies aren't white but a grey tone. Filters can lighten or darken the sky tone - a green or red filter works as expected. IMHO - its possible to get monochrome results from it that aren't reproducible with a color digital camera.
Ultimately, its your art - what works for me might not be best for you.