KindaSpikey wrote:
So, I'm not concerned about myself, (I've been here long enough now to understand how it works), but I do worry a little for the new members to UHH. These members "new" to this (great in my opinion) site, quite often have very little experience with photography. Maybe they are embarking on hopefully a lifelong career path, or perhaps they are somewhat like me, an enthusiastic amature who derives a great deal of pleasure from this wonderful hobby. It doesn't really matter at this point which of these people I'm referring to. The point is this. Let's just imagine a new member for example, with very little photographic experience. They've gone out and after some research, bought the best equipment they can afford and justify. They've gone out and taken pictures of pretty much everything they can think of, and among those hundreds of shots, there are a few that they are kind of proud of and happy with. So they join UHH and look for someplace to show their work. They look through the list of options and decide against "critique", and "Photo Analysis", they don't have enough confidence for that yet, but they see the gallery, and for them it's the perfect place just to put their pictures for everyone to see, and it makes them feel good about themselves seeing their shots up there among other much better and experienced photographers. So here's where I see the potential problem. If they put their pictures there, just to simply be looked at, (like in a "gallery"), and then start getting criticized right off the bat, with total "experienced" strangers telling them what's wrong with their pride and joy, don't you think that could have a really negative impact on them moving forward? Surely encouragement would make them want to make a better picture next time, and post something new. If they think that they made a pretty good picture, but people start telling them what's wrong with it, they could get disheartened very quickly and maybe even give up before they even really begin. Critiques definitely have their place, and are incredibly useful, (I know it's helped me), but only if specifically asked for, or if you're posting in a "critique" forum. Maybe I'm wrong, perhaps you'll disagree, but I do get concerned for some of our new members. I
So, I'm not concerned about myself, (I've been her... (
show quote)