PNagy wrote:
Zophman: 480,000 Americans die each year due to diseases caused by smoking (cdc.gov) Why isn't smoking illegal?
Nagy: Please provide credible evidence for that level of mortality from second hand smoke. It seems like abject nonsense to me. Smoking in most public places is illegal, and very few people still smoke today. A very thin minority of people I know have contracted or died of lung cancer. I do not know a single non-smoker who has had lung cancer. I personally knew more than one who has been shot to death, even though the annual carnage by that route is downward from 40,000 a year (dramatically reduced during the Obama era.)
There is a difference between the proven mortality caused by smoking vis a vis firearms. The smokers k**l only themselves, while shooters k**l themselves, as well as others. Nevertheless, if you are implying that smoking should be illegal, I agree. It is a monstrous form of self abuse, and the industry should be destroyed.
Zophman: 480,000 Americans die each year due to di... (
show quote)
The CDC has published these findings regarding second hand smoke (Google is an amazing tool...you should try it. It's easy!). 41,300 people die each year from second hand smoke. Smokers not only k**l themselves but other innocent victims. Yes, in most communities smoking in public places is illegal or at least significantly restricted. So why does the second hand smoke death rate remain? And does your personal experience regarding lung cancer qualify as scientific study? I doubt it. Your premise concerning the proven mortality of fire arms and smoking is without merit as evidenced by studies from numerous organizations including the CDC.