I like the color one much better...warmer and inviting.
Interesting...really liked the composition in #3. A little fuzzy in the left corner. Number 1 was also interesting. I would have liked a little higher angle and tighter to the wall. Did you take it in color because I think with all the wood, it might be interesting too.
Great shot, great color but agree that a crop of the extra wall is more pleasing...
Enjoyed the train. Great composition--only wish the pickup was not there.
Beautiful edit on a beautiful capture. It moved me.