Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Picking a picture-taker for the Princess: D5600 v D7200
Page <<first <prev 5 of 5
Mar 20, 2019 13:39:33   #
cdayton
 
I bought my wife a D5200 several years ago and she loves it. I wanted to start using the D5200 as a backup and bought her a Sony a6000 but she rejected it (too small with confusing menus) so now the Sony is my backup. I vote for the D5600.

Reply
Mar 20, 2019 16:42:59   #
Bill_de Loc: US
 
The D5600 should fit the bill.

By the time your wife feels the need for a newer camera, and has the time to use it, you can give her your D850. By then you will have moved on. This will occur a couple of weeks after your new baby graduates from college.

---

Reply
Mar 20, 2019 17:12:36   #
Architect1776 Loc: In my mind
 
ngrea wrote:
I find the articulated screen on the d5600 very useful for getting low shots, such as floor level babies. She can always start with auto and then experiment with other settings. Don’t start her off with a lot of explanation. When auto doesn’t give her the results she wants she will figure it out



Reply
 
 
Mar 20, 2019 19:16:54   #
donald4u Loc: California
 
Live view is nice. But it drains the batteries. I have had the Nikon D40,D5100 and now the 7100 because of the buffer is better. I would vote for the 5600 . One of the features I am sure you would like is the articulating screen. Keep it simple.

Reply
Mar 20, 2019 19:37:07   #
CatMarley Loc: North Carolina
 
donald4u wrote:
Live view is nice. But it drains the batteries. I have had the Nikon D40,D5100 and now the 7100 because of the buffer is better. I would vote for the 5600 . One of the features I am sure you would like is the articulating screen. Keep it simple.


Yes I find the articulating screen on the Fujis extremely useful for low level shots of children and puppies.

Reply
Mar 20, 2019 21:23:29   #
JJP31717
 
nikonnate wrote:
Hey everybody

I did a search on the topic (specifically "d5600") but didn't get very far so I'm straight-up asking.

My wife and I recently had a kid, our first, and she's in picture mode. She wants to take a lot of candid snaps so she can have prints and small canvases made up but only has her phone. I'm sure many of you understand. She likes what I do with my D850 and Sunday night said "maybe you can teach me to use your camera because I don't like my phone as much." I think that's great, but yesterday afternoon I introduced her to the concept of aperture and ISO. I figure going from that level to a D850 is like getting your permit at 15 and having your behind-the-wheel training with a Corvette on a track. And she's a little clumsy....

I looked around at Nikon's APS-C cameras and like the D5600 and D7200 specs. I looked at each of them in-hand last night, I like the simpler menus, I like how each feels in-hand (5600 for the light, compact feel like a mirrorless, the 7200 because it's like a small D850), and I like that each has fewer buttons. She'll like that too because she says just looking at my D850 makes her anxious with all the controls.


So, specifically, how does each fare for entry-level users? I want her to have some creative ability - she'll grow in to either I'm sure - but for now I am looking at pleasantness and ease of use, ease of growing in to the next level, and obvious limitations. I am NOT looking at how many dials each has or how many card slots; that stuff doesn't matter to someone who just learned yesterday what aperture is. How does each handle low-light noise? Which one would you pick for someone interested in portrait and candids, and basic wildlife (like the squirrel in the tree or ducks on the dock next to the boat, not birds in flight).

TIA
Hey everybody br br I did a search on the topic (... (show quote)


I have had the 5600 for 18 months and it is easy to use and will do all that ur wife would like. The articulating screen give lots of options - live view works great & so does the video ability.

Reply
Mar 20, 2019 22:17:49   #
AKARC
 
Street shooting, Ybor City, Tampa with D3300, 50mm, 1.8, iso 800, f3.5, no flash, autofocus, 2 years ago. I have more expensive D7200 drives me crazy with noise. Don't know if having the dials versus menu hunting is worth the price difference. Either/or, were it my wife Id take her somewhere and let her make the decision, if I do it, whatever I choose will not work out <G>.



Reply
 
 
Mar 20, 2019 22:22:20   #
srt101fan
 
nikonnate wrote:
Hey everybody

I did a search on the topic (specifically "d5600") but didn't get very far so I'm straight-up asking.

My wife and I recently had a kid, our first, and she's in picture mode. She wants to take a lot of candid snaps so she can have prints and small canvases made up but only has her phone. I'm sure many of you understand. She likes what I do with my D850 and Sunday night said "maybe you can teach me to use your camera because I don't like my phone as much." I think that's great, but yesterday afternoon I introduced her to the concept of aperture and ISO. I figure going from that level to a D850 is like getting your permit at 15 and having your behind-the-wheel training with a Corvette on a track. And she's a little clumsy....

I looked around at Nikon's APS-C cameras and like the D5600 and D7200 specs. I looked at each of them in-hand last night, I like the simpler menus, I like how each feels in-hand (5600 for the light, compact feel like a mirrorless, the 7200 because it's like a small D850), and I like that each has fewer buttons. She'll like that too because she says just looking at my D850 makes her anxious with all the controls.


So, specifically, how does each fare for entry-level users? I want her to have some creative ability - she'll grow in to either I'm sure - but for now I am looking at pleasantness and ease of use, ease of growing in to the next level, and obvious limitations. I am NOT looking at how many dials each has or how many card slots; that stuff doesn't matter to someone who just learned yesterday what aperture is. How does each handle low-light noise? Which one would you pick for someone interested in portrait and candids, and basic wildlife (like the squirrel in the tree or ducks on the dock next to the boat, not birds in flight).

TIA
Hey everybody br br I did a search on the topic (... (show quote)


You've gotten good comments re the pros and cons of the two cameras. Your wife seems seriously interested in taking pictures of the coming child and I applaud that (I took lots of pictures of my kids and I'm very glad I did!).

But you need to gauge her level of interest in PHOTOGRAPHY...How much does she want to learn? How far does she want to take her "picture-taking"?

I shot with film cameras for many years. I went digital with a Kodak, moved to a Nikon D50, and now use a Nikon D5300. I am very happy with that camera and have no intention of "upgrading" to a more "capable" model...

Some here have suggested that your wife skip the "entry level" cameras and go for the more "capable" ones right away. Does she need these capabilities? Is she going to pursue a photographic journey to a point where she will need these capabilities? These are the questions you and your wife need to answer.

For what it's worth, I think the D5xxx series are great cameras and I'm sure the D5600 would serve her well.....

Happy parenthood!

Reply
Mar 20, 2019 22:45:04   #
inbigd
 
I think your D750 allows you to preview effects of changes to aperture, iso, shutter speed in live view like the evf on a mirrorless does. My D610 does not and I don't know if the cameras you are considering do either.

Reply
Mar 21, 2019 00:49:25   #
Murray Loc: New Westminster
 
D7200 would be my choice as it will accept many more lenses and autofocus. I have a D7100 and D5100 on the Nikon side, and the 5100 rarely come out of its bag.

Reply
Mar 21, 2019 09:13:59   #
foggypreacher Loc: Dickinson, Texas
 

Reply
Page <<first <prev 5 of 5
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.