LoneRangeFinder Loc: Left field

I also have used both. I wish I had started with the Arca-Swiss clamps. Just so pleasant to use.

imagemeister Loc: mid east Florida

You could also use one of these - MUCH cheaper ! - https://www.ebay.com/itm/QR-50-Quick-Release-Clamp-Plate-For-Arca-SWISS-Manfrotto-Gitzo-Transition-Socket/332501203508?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l9372

..

jcboy3

If you are happy with the Manfrotto RC2 system, then pick up an RC2 ball head for your tripod to replace the RC4 head. The RC2 is quick to release and mount.

I can say, I really do not like the RC4 system. I still have and use a 410 Junior, but I put an Arca clamp on the RC4 plate, and now I never remove the RC4 plate.

I mostly use Arca system now, and have ball heads, gimbal heads, tilt heads, and clamps (for use on Manfrotto video heads). But it can be a big expense to move.

The big advantage to Arca is that you can put a custom base plate on your camera that matches the profile of the base, so it's not very obtrusive, and they are non-twist for added stability. I have custom base plates on most of my cameras.

amfoto1 Loc: San Jose, Calif. USA

If you are happy with the Manfrotto quick release system and it does all you need it to do, by all means stick with it and don't change to the Arca-Swiss system. Simply get another Manfrotto head that uses the same QR plates.

Arca-Swiss is only "better" or "necessary" for certain things.... such as gimbal heads that are used with very large telephotos. That forced me to switch from Manfrotto to A-S QR system. I also was using different format film cameras, so had two different Manfrotto... and was able to instead use A-S type QR on all of them instead. An extra long A-S lens plate also can serve as a "macro slider"... a simple, lightweight alternative to a macro focusing stage. But, there was significant cost in switching over... new lens plates for all my lenses with tripod mounting rings, new camera plates for all my cameras. I even replaced platforms on a couple Manfrotto heads, to be able to use them with the A-S system (which isn't easy with all Manfrotto heads... some that are cast as a single piece would require machining by a shop to modify them).

jeep_daddy Loc: Prescott AZ

I can't find the MPMXPROA3 ball head you speak of but if you like the Arca Swiss plate system, then you can probably unscrew the Manfrotto clamp and install Arca Swiss clamps in there place. They can be purchased separately at many online stores and plates are cheap on eBay. I use Arca Swiss plates and clamps for everything. Or, since you already have all Manfrotto stuff, you can simply purchase some new quick release Manfrotto plates to use on your new cameras.

jcboy3

Replacement Arca clamps are available for some brands of ball head, but not most. The issue is that they all use a different anti-twist mount. I've done some replacements; it is expensive and troublesome.

You would think that brands that converted to Arca (such as Vanguard) would use consistent anti-twist design, and provide upgrade clamps for their older heads. That would help with brand loyalty. Haven't seen that.

Better to just get an Arca ball head.

ggenova64

Arc-Swiss from RRS.

pahtspix

I have Arca-Type plates and clamps for ALL of my gear that connects to just about anything!!..I dropped the Manfrotto/ Bogen type connectors about 10 years ago, and I have not looked back.. The Arca-Style plates and clamps have become so commonplace, that even the rotating lens-collar on my Tamron 150-600mm G2 has an arca plate built into the mount so it eradicates the need to add an additional plate to mount on a gimbal type or ball headed tripod (or monopod!!). I say go "ARCA"..It's here NOW and in the future!!

LoneRangeFinder Loc: Left field

jeep_daddy Loc: Prescott AZ

ez22 Loc: The World

I've had my Arca-Swiss since 2000 and there's no reason I won't have it for the rest of my life. Would not want to live without it. I think I paid around $500 for it back then.

ggenova64

Hi Hedgehoggers

I decided last night at a Photo Excursion to scrap the idea of purchasing a RRS tripod after the bushings fell out while adjusting the height. Has any one experienced this?
I am still watching and waiting for replies on a Gitzo make and model with an Arc-Swiss Head. I might consider a Head from RRS.

Gino

StevenBrownPhoto Loc: Excelsior, MN

This is the best way to go for another reason. You don’t need to remove the plate for a battery change!