Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Water torture testing the Top 4 Pro DSLR Cameras
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
May 19, 2018 08:20:36   #
rehess Loc: South Bend, Indiana, USA
 
lamiaceae wrote:
Seeing as I am a hobbyist and no one is paying me to risk destroying one of my cameras, I don't feel any shot I might take is worth putting a camera through a deluge. That is not to say I have not gotten some sprinkling on a camera ever. I can think of three times I've gotten one of my DSLRs slightly wet. That is two of my four DSLR cameras anyway. My Pentax K-100D is converted to full-time Infrared use so I would not even have that camera with me on a cloudy day. My Pentax K-20D is definitely water resistant as you can see o-rings, grommets, and locking "doors" on it, and the advertising stressed its weather or environmental resistance. That was not my main rationale for buying it though. I have had no problems with water, i.e., light rain getting into my main camera, a Pentax K-5, but I don't believe it is as well sealed as the older K-20D because it has gotten dust inside and had to be professionally disassembled and cleaned. The poor thing even had gotten food on it and some of that over time may have worked its way inside. My newest camera is a used Pentax K-3, but I have no idea about its weather proofing as I have not had it long and I have not had it out in the elements yet (dust, sand, mist, rain).

I would not expect my Omega 4x5" View Camera to do well in rain nor my 4x5" wooden folding Field Camera. I do also have several film SLRs and other cameras (film & digital) but I keep them dry. Oh, I used to own a Pentax medium format Pentax 6x7. I believe that was well sealed. I may have gotten a bit of water on that. All in all I think it is best to keep electronics like digital cameras dry and not stored in humid locations.

I also noticed the testers in the study said they did not have a Pentax, Panasonic, or Fuji-Film camera available for testing. Nice they tested a Nikon D850 as it is new. But they should have also tested a Nikon D5 for comparison. I'd wonder, did Nikon F2, F3, or F4 cameras ever leak?
Seeing as I am a hobbyist and no one is paying me ... (show quote)

Several years ago, a "cloud burst" began while my wife and I were on a 'birding' walk. If I had still been using my Canon Rebel, I would have quickly stuffed it into my camera bag. This was a year after I had purchased my Pentax K-30, though, so I just took pictures as she tried to figure out how to use her new rain 'slicker'. I wasn't looking for water, but I wasn't going to allow it to deter me, either.

Reply
May 19, 2018 08:35:01   #
Blurryeyed Loc: NC Mountains.
 
LFingar wrote:
SS, are you confusing a pop-up flash with a hot shoe? All Canon DSLR's have hot shoes, even the 1DX series.


Good call, he had me scratching my head.

Reply
May 19, 2018 08:37:45   #
Blurryeyed Loc: NC Mountains.
 
I think that moisture is one of the reasons that Canon's top of the line bodies do not have articulating screens, I used my 60D in very light misty rain, even inside a plastic grocery bag moisture entered the camera and created all kinds of problems, since I have not owned another camera with that type of screen.

Reply
 
 
May 19, 2018 09:27:51   #
OviedoPhotos
 
OK, but 10$ for a hot shoe cover???

Reply
May 19, 2018 10:14:20   #
SharpShooter Loc: NorCal
 
LFingar wrote:
SS, are you confusing a pop-up flash with a hot shoe? All Canon DSLR's have hot shoes, even the 1DX series.


LF, yes, sorry I was thinking pop-up!!
Sorry for the confusion.
I was testing you guys to see that you’re on the ball!!!
SS

Reply
May 19, 2018 10:17:33   #
ras422 Loc: Virginia
 
Thanks for the info just heard about this the other day.btw did not ever think that you did the tests. Rich

Reply
May 19, 2018 10:51:03   #
billnikon Loc: Pennsylvania/Ohio/Florida/Maui/Oregon/Vermont
 
Dr.Nikon wrote:
Wow .. it is a good thing I stumbled onto the article Water Tourture Tests for D850..., google it ..I thought I had bought all the D850 accessories I needed .., seems I left out one important one!

Nikon makes a BS-3 Hot Shoe Cover .....what for ..., well .., just for looks and to seek an added accessory ....NO .. as a hot shoe protection ...oh ..OK ..

But ..., But .., come to find out my D850 has a little secret ... when exposed to rain/ water splash .. the D850 L E A K S .. what ..., NO ... YES !

To solve this .., NIKON makes a BS-3 Hot Shoe Cover ...order 2 .. they are cheap and ...easy to misplace ..
Wow .. it is a good thing I stumbled onto the arti... (show quote)


First of all, I NEVER take my gear out in the rain or snow, NEVER. If someone wants to take their gear out and have it rained on or put a hose to that's OK for them, but I would never even consider it. Yes, my gear is all weather sealed except for my Nikon 200-500. I carry a plastic bag from the grocery store for the chance it might rain. Yes, I understand that I can take my gear out in the rain and snow, but I don't.
When I was a photojournalist and I was using the papers equipment and had to get the shot, that was different. I respect my equipment too much to be messing with the rain. I do however have a personal solution, I have a Nikon AW 130 for the rain and I do it sometimes if I see a good shot opportunity. The Nikon AW 130 takes great shots and yes, I am not afraid to take it out in the rain, my personal Nikon, Sony, and Canon gear stay dry in a humid free cabinet. And yes, humidity and rain go together and will wear out the best of gear.

Reply
 
 
May 19, 2018 12:07:08   #
Billynikon Loc: Atlanta
 
A few years ago I used my D200 in a rainstorm when I had to get pictures of a house. The D90 stayed in the car. D200 is still working.

Reply
May 19, 2018 13:30:24   #
rehess Loc: South Bend, Indiana, USA
 
billnikon wrote:
First of all, I NEVER take my gear out in the rain or snow, NEVER. If someone wants to take their gear out and have it rained on or put a hose to that's OK for them, but I would never even consider it. Yes, my gear is all weather sealed except for my Nikon 200-500. I carry a plastic bag from the grocery store for the chance it might rain. Yes, I understand that I can take my gear out in the rain and snow, but I don't.

I show respect for my Pentax equipment by using it to its fullest. I have taken it out in snow and rain because that is where the pictures are.

added: During last year's hurricane season, someone wondered why most images shared here are taken during good weather. Your post may help to explain that.

Reply
May 19, 2018 13:40:27   #
Cdouthitt Loc: Traverse City, MI
 
Not surprising the Olympus passed with no issues.

Reply
May 19, 2018 14:22:43   #
farwest Loc: Utah
 
Jerrin1 wrote:
I recently swapped my D500 and EM1 mark II for a Sony A7III. Prior to the swap I fully realised that my A7III would not be a weatherproof as my D55 and EM1.2, so I immediatley purchased a rain cover which covers both my A7III and my Sony 100 - 400mm at the same time. Problem solved. I won't be sweating over it.


Glad you had luck in the rain with your D500 but I wouldn't recommend it as I had mine in a light drizzle and the next day it wouldn't fire up. Sent it to nikon 368.00 later I'll get it back.

Reply
 
 
May 19, 2018 15:03:15   #
Spirit Vision Photography Loc: Behind a Camera.
 
I use the same hot shoe cover on my F100 film bodies.

Reply
May 19, 2018 15:36:37   #
drklrd Loc: Cincinnati Ohio
 
billnikon wrote:
First of all, I NEVER take my gear out in the rain or snow, NEVER. If someone wants to take their gear out and have it rained on or put a hose to that's OK for them, but I would never even consider it. Yes, my gear is all weather sealed except for my Nikon 200-500. I carry a plastic bag from the grocery store for the chance it might rain. Yes, I understand that I can take my gear out in the rain and snow, but I don't.
When I was a photojournalist and I was using the papers equipment and had to get the shot, that was different. I respect my equipment too much to be messing with the rain. I do however have a personal solution, I have a Nikon AW 130 for the rain and I do it sometimes if I see a good shot opportunity. The Nikon AW 130 takes great shots and yes, I am not afraid to take it out in the rain, my personal Nikon, Sony, and Canon gear stay dry in a humid free cabinet. And yes, humidity and rain go together and will wear out the best of gear.
First of all, I NEVER take my gear out in the rain... (show quote)


Apparently you do not make money shooting sports outdoors. I do and I will put up with light rain under an umbrella until I know I have all the shots I need. When the wind blows my umbrella away I go to my truck to stay dry. If the shots are not mad I don't get paid. So I have learned to some extent being rained upon is acceptable. Just how wet it becomes is where I draw a line.

Reply
May 19, 2018 17:12:06   #
gwilliams6
 
Fact not static testing , I have used my Sony A7RII in the constant rain for three weeks trekking through Scottish Highlands and Hebrides Islands last fall with NO water problems. Do I submerge my cameras in water, or drench them with a running hose, NO. But in real-world usage I am no less confident using my Sony gear in poor weather, as I was using my Canon DSLRs in poor weather. I love all these static testers. Other pros from Australia to Europe and across America use their Sony gear for pro wildlife shooting in snow, sub zero temps, blowing sand and spraying water and surf with confidence and success, creating stunning professional images.. FYI, I now have Sony A6500, A7RIII (upgrade from my A7RII) and A7III. Right now I am in Caribbean island of St. Martin where I will use my A7III with no worries from rain, wind spray and beach sand. Cheers

Reply
May 19, 2018 19:10:25   #
wdross Loc: Castle Rock, Colorado
 
gwilliams6 wrote:
Fact not static testing , I have used my Sony A7RII in the constant rain for three weeks trekking through Scottish Highlands and Hebrides Islands last fall with NO water problems. Do I submerge my cameras in water, or drench them with a running hose, NO. But in real-world usage I am no less confident using my Sony gear in poor weather, as I was using my Canon DSLRs in poor weather. I love all these static testers. Other pros from Australia to Europe and across America use their Sony gear for pro wildlife shooting in snow, sub zero temps, blowing sand and spraying water and surf with confidence and success, creating stunning professional images.. FYI, I now have Sony A6500, A7RIII (upgrade from my A7RII) and A7III. Right now I am in Caribbean island of St. Martin where I will use my A7III with no worries from rain, wind spray and beach sand. Cheers
Fact not static testing , I have used my Sony A7RI... (show quote)


It wasn't totally static. In the test, they did run a portion of it using shutter and function buttons while spraying "rain" on them from a hose. Yes, it was limited use in the "rain", but the water test did run 30 minutes long total.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.