Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
Operation Paperclip: Welcome Mat for Nazi War Criminals - Occupied Germany 1945
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
Sep 9, 2017 19:08:48   #
RichardQ Loc: Colorado
 
William J Renard wrote:
Now that the Nazis have come and gone, What about, Cocesscu, Tito and the rest of the ilk that destroyed the German minority in Eastern Europe, with our approval????


I have to admire your faithfulness to your cause, William! There was nothing we could do about the internal decisions in those Communist lands governed by rebels who even defied Moscow. When Tito shot down two U.S. cargo planes, using fighter planes and holding survivors hostage, all we did was start using one armed B-17 to accompany subsequent flights until he "apologized" and returned the hostages. It wasn't worth starting WW III. I'm afraid the Allies had little sympathy for any German minorities in other lands during those postwar years.

Reply
Sep 9, 2017 20:11:40   #
William J Renard
 
Sometimes we walk with the Devil to get to Heaven? The big wigs lead, and tell the small people that they are justefied in what they tell us, this has gone on since the inception of history, the sadness is that the average
innocent small person is the one who suffers most. Leaders, Politicians and lawyers, sometimes fit into the catagory of LIARS!!!

Reply
Sep 9, 2017 20:45:51   #
Quinn 4
 
Werner von Braun hands were as dirt as the Nazis we hanged at Nuremberg. Truman - Eisenhower - Kennedy all knew about those ex Nazis working and living here in the good old USA. USA landed on the moon over the bones of those people the Nazis killed. This is not any thing new, it came out back in the 1970s. I am taking a back by the fact not one person, but all of you did not known about is.

Reply
 
 
Sep 10, 2017 21:51:40   #
RichardQ Loc: Colorado
 
[quote=ecblackiii]
RichardQ wrote:
In early 1945, a top-secret, unauthorized plot was developed in Washington to gradually bring some 1,700 "elite" Nazi scientists and technicians to America while concealing their hideous histories of gruesome war crimes.

Why? So their advanced knowledge in rocketry, missiles, aeronautics, bionics and chemical warfare could help the U.S. prepare for an anticipated future war with Soviet Russia. The Pentagon plotters were U.S. military intelligence officers who believed their deception was necessary for our national security.

Similar programs were initiated by Britain, France and Russia.



This is insinuating more of the matter than warranted by facts. There were actually 13 Nurenberg War Crimes trials, with the first trial (of 24 indicted major Nazi leaders) being the most well known. In all, 185 Nazis were put on trial (and not all of them were convicted) There were several million members of the Nazi party, but the Allied powers felt no justification for more than 185 of them to be charged with a war crime. So painting the German scientists selected to be brought to America with the same character smear as those who actually committed atrocities, is fake history. Membership in the Nazi party was essentially required for many positions, but membership alone has never been considered a war crime. There is thus no reason for all to be tarred with the same brush of war crimes as those who were actually indicted.
In early 1945, a top-secret, unauthorized plot was... (show quote)


Thank you for your interest and comments, ecblackiii. I have to remind you that there were far more Nazi war crimes trials than the 13 Nuremberg trials, since the British, French, Russians, Poles, Italians, Czechs, etc. conducted their own trials inside their Occupation Zones and homelands -- and the U.S. Army ran peripheral courts such as the March-April 1946 trial of 61 Nazi war criminals (ages 23 to 63) in Dachau for their atrocities in the huge Mauthausen Camp in Austria. At least 165,000 POWs and German nationals died there between Jan. 1942 and early May, 1945.

According to Nazi Party records, only 10 percent of the German population were members in 1945, which means 90 percent were not. That would indicate that membership was not obligatory. In fact, some of the Paperclip Nazis were not Party members but held responsible posts. Von Braun contended he joined because that helped him to get funding for his rocketry obsession.

In the case of Paperclip, membership in the Nazi Party automatically barred a German from entering the USA, under strict orders from President Truman. The Paperclip officers deliberately disobeyed that order, qualifying them for severe courtsmartial -- which never happened. I also must remind you that all the Paperclip candidates were subjected to intense interrogations, from which detailed dossiers were compiled listing their war crimes as they themselves described them. Those dossiers were held secret for decades, and some, like von Braun's, are still not released. When they were reluctantly released to reporter Linda Hunt, without the forgeries, they revealed horrendous crimes committed by scientists of all stripes. Those facts do warrant my insinuations, IMHO.



Reply
Sep 11, 2017 00:38:44   #
kemosabe
 
Albert - NZ wrote:
Why does'nt War Criminals apply to the winner of a war? I would say that Harry Truman would have been on top of the list. Deny it?


Why would you say that? The decision has been proven to have saved approximately a million American lives. I guess that saving American lives would not be important to you.

Reply
Sep 11, 2017 14:07:39   #
Quinn 4
 
Kemosabe, you get your facts mix up. The people who work on the A-Bomb, had to get out of Germany and other places because the Nazis were hunting them down to kill them. Most of them got to America before America got into the war. Werner Von Braun and people like him came after the war.

Reply
Sep 11, 2017 15:08:51   #
RichardQ Loc: Colorado
 
pendennis wrote:
Werner Von Braun's research at Peenemunde was in the realm of rocket and guided missile development, not development of an atomic bomb. Germany stopped development of the atomic bomb in late 1942, since there were insufficient funds to continue such an expensive project. The German scientists proved theoretically that a bomb could be built, but the engineering costs were prohibitive. Rockets and guided missiles as weapons were conventional weapons using high explosives. Any thoughts of using missiles to deliver nuclear weapons were strictly theoretical at the time, with no engineering capabilities.

By the time Nazi Germany had surrendered, we had already developed the atomic bomb, so any German contribution would only be theoretical, not practical. We were desperately trying to keep the atomic bomb secrets away from the Soviet Union, but were being sold out Soviet agents within the Manhattan Project itself.

The Pentagon, Navy and Army Air Forces were interested in rocketry for a variety of reasons, and even the U.S. State Department wanted to get German rocket scientists here to continue research and engineering.
Werner Von Braun's research at Peenemunde was in t... (show quote)


Many thanks for your interesting and perceptive comments, pendennis. One fact that has been overlooked in this discussion of A-bombs is the inclination of physicists to gossip among themselves, across national borders, even in wartimes. They are practically an international garden club, sharing personal and professional information. They did a lot of letter writing before, during and after WW II (which today is replaced with e-mails, or worse, tweets). An example was a now-famous and controversial meeting between Nazi Germany's eminent physicist,Werner Heissenberg, and his Danish mentor, Prof. Niels Bohr in September, 1941, after Nazi Germany invaded Denmark. Heissenberg defended his work on an A-bomb for Hitler, and Bohr vigorously criticised it. The friends parted as enemies. Bohr and his family escaped to England and America, where he joined the Manhattan Project to create the American A-bomb. The incident generated books and a Broadway play, "Copenhagen" by Michael Frayn. Sounds like a Hollywood melodrama.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.